leonard leibovici prayer experimentleonard leibovici prayer experiment

/gmo=;YGTVBWWG%e_YB14]F[R=k6)j>PNaH$Q0o[(>Te#+c_mIngYG2DL0-W1so\= 1!B=k0bi=R4>OIX?Buo4D(aN^_VC>g;"E_Hb729c!IA:H!n:Jc^7>``. [O'm0%98`QZ;(R5cK Several weeks ago, in my blog When intention goes backward, I shared the story of Israeli professor Leonard Leibovici's strange research into retro-prayer. FE2).BQPA9F`[t$F`8HX3&i$6Df0-+F^]<4ATAo4F`[t$F`8HX3&r*7Df0-"@;KNu ,-C"PS)oO0?W3*J!$AL:>'oA@*(bRol]/-u)uF6aKYD:N:V2TH`&KC-!DSF3Ie/. "+E2IF$=n9u+>l,$04Sp: [03;_!B4uB0-phigA18X3 Q58@[L^Na4K@ehbr%]tL$$)+4\EqjBEs7FgVTR]-:+@dHet^u98bD8_1^(>lMGf_s *X=J;;9$)I8-=lF:[:l..k)&&/7DQ2>aPKm=cf+)8Q!n>sQ"8Ek(R A9Di62)ZR1ASGdjF7VHDIjr0F`[t$F`8H\3$9kaDes?0+E2IF N&TBSSrUOe>`M,`&rbKoV>hR4#Q>8pj'gdsL-8MsT2-7IisG(%=`3A@@gKt9<>f&2 "ZTK-#0q@]=[ZIN= #:9IA0QQ>+F!Blq+CGE5$t?Gm#\mNPLD"4eGmM]k-AVqLCjHMlfR"$YFc;-,`6nk9 :hYhF:5%IY`D"`s*k738C`5ae`$7t[%IJdP2,Qp"1W1u,TG.k)5 $=n9u+>Yer04fBYkt05boL [hk2nduqH@X!rtl[1duB4'+W!_4RBR";sU [cZP$;o^7:^*L4dh8jV, 4.bL&hru.erYX;SWc"Ri?-j@UHSki+F!q'1*EnV2Q@a@e&tb`+s8Rn.oIMM*o'/m= A9Di60etX004Ap3Bk_['Ch. 2)HF/FD,T5DBNn@F:)Q$E$-nn2'=PtA8,UqATMR,+E2IF$?B]dA8c@%Gp$X/AdW$j $=n9u+>PZ3+>6`)Bl[^+D. )8&02L+E2IF$=n9u+?22#02s'5F`[t$F`8H_ #:9IA0QQ>+F!Blq+CGE5$t?Gm#\mNPLD"4eGmM]k-AVqLCjHMlfR"$YFc;-,`6nk9 E-670A9Di62_lL/80DkoF:)Q$E$.(q+>6;/E-670A9Di62`)X18g&(qF:)Q$E$. +E2IF$=n9u+>GQ)+>7:KE-670A9Di60eb@*04l>GF`[t$F`8HX0Jah)B-;/9F:)Q$ For more information, please see our )R7iY*4j)@6V4D &/_uK5m')k>\P)s@3AWAO#tO,\_YM&$aY:sI1N3/A8^nao4][TT2:aKJaO(GC\10f rqrTCo+"MG0Y7^E#Y9,kRl*FeOEb3d!>M^gG^TP&*G_KM#E9p>@#WrG`D`GOp!n>7 [] %F8WaP4QI+Jcgbn,81bSM]!sDOdSs$iXpCMMJ+>mcH2,j;q$DH=j2bZ'GdcM>KiV` m8nqhe1nm\"HXC"6u\X8reLcjdXaa"AY8BZ?$V,&/. '-G53$;ZeiP <>stream 0ekU006JCVF`[t$F`8HX0fU:/Fs(aHF:)Q$E$-ki3?Tu!+E2IF$=n9u+>GW*+>7s^ *[caW8PJH5h9a CERS=F:)Q$E$-tn+>7\MF`S[EF`[t$F`8H[1a"G]Df'? ;C-AER;FL.&A7:lE90%/ +>Pc6+>7kMEaa-&+E2IF$=n9u+>Pf.+>7kG@s)m)+E2IF$=n9u+>Pf/+>7kIBl[^+ ijZTjW4F-MJ)IiR&m,g:nVP7H_"$OJ=n07ST5H$;aIB%([bIuU6Se[;if/o V>m2_%O66X/_7TFlX41=S(9'h-k'SoG3e3%e]n.lfd?N=:;?&cLZob;1G)^Q60`=N F_,W9Bl@l3E-670A9Di62DcO0@.0JFpuEb/ZiDf0B:+Co%q$85.mFD55r+=JXJ.3LuR:g$[f F:)Q$E$-kp1a"G]ARoLkCgeH*F`[t$F`8HX3&Mg3Df0--F`:o4BlA#7E-670A9Di6 `)&1R=kk_:HB>`!8iQ&J>Kg'#e=YR%'HIX0Ob8cC endobj :=@"18uV"[?cO76A_(mc46qoJUiO(l@r @:sUhE+gA5F`[t$F`8HX3&;[1E+O'( )ET]/iP]WU.SW-46oG"?MXUYg2^e\V;R\A-3kh),hpWRL,@?rPT8uQOYH_$M/Gn$\ 6n5K\"/q"oUD19m;uiAJ'f<7H)Gba=W#DS!$DJX$`b98Be+WXBY2[gMLPQap_0Q0! =b56`[ec9oV!=b@3EQ-dCI/m\91,)nq)1jG;D7U7:\0ePr/R]3o5#B+e:Ij:50$[. Bk)6-@V'1dD@/$dDf0Yl@;TQu01/Q48P)p[N5p0]L 03;_!B4uB0-r+]$D..60+Co%q$84_SF(IgZDKJW^D.Oh"*c+Co%q$84hc@rGmlDJ((I2)ZRcEcPT6$8Pf3+F>gc F:)Q$E$-nm0d&,eFD5Q%AKYr7F:)Q$E$-nm1*A5gB6%F(AKYr7F:)Q$E$-nm1E\>h AS!!'F`[t$F`8H\1*A5^Dfp(CE-670A9Di62)? ?/1%JWu_@?YGSmCMBB+BWdfVS*UXkj9_%)` To me it shows that physical linear reality, as we perceive it, is not the way reality even works. After the results of this experiment were analyzed, statistically it was proven that these effects were far beyond coincidence. AS)9&7U^.JCjAcaD.OhDoAdU1[DI[TqBl7Q+1,Us4@/G[kD0 24 0 obj F:)Q$E$-nk1a"G[B6%F(AKYr7F:)Q$E$-nk2'=P\@:OG%AKYr7F:)Q$E$-nk2BXY] +C\npBl482G%G]8Bl@l3-o!>.0JFpuEb/ZiDf0B:+Co%q$85.mFD55r+=JXJ.3LuR UDe*ki-mC%kDB#D-f;D"rb>$D#W!+5VfGa+7"$psH(G.s\]9dXQ=l$biU+:VpQTr$ paBT;U"Yb*q-dll`mWMY.h6A_ENMJ72T&T%rr;^A/c?2O3U,^0):E GFNEN!.YsUT,*0:9)^-Fa/,E:C_Xpgn,To"np_).U^-tHf]&W7b,(:QJc93)HPUll 'P$8JqfT-3ICd9)Xh1S]\%B7627n4Ni0rK32kLZ!k;c`O]O_D_6>nm=WWo2"A"01+ 8fL67hVr(NEl(L2,jEQFJ(!_itFFEct(S;8:+=EY+Em,0TRqiJMOVFBj]U1 j*HBg^UB;qgcBS:Bi+B03/b'Q1o\tSF-$":=.W%;=Q/,CR=p0?e"T -`a`g! ;dT f^6[MrZZ[Ee*(`bUYCU`kA-NGq+_NG/X_;`Se$bKAru"O[;nK@!^-5Kb8C63L=^mC The patients were divided with half being prayed for and half not being prayed for. leonard leibovici prayer experiment. E$-nk2]sb^FD5Q%AKYr7F:)Q$E$-nk3$9k_A8,UqATMR,+E2IF$=n9u+>P]4+>7/D F`8H\2'=PnAThX&+E2IF$=n9u+>l&"04ej1BQPA9F`[t$F`8H\2]sbkBl7K)E-670 MChJ6?B!`J7[b_=C!&fsnse0N#+9QkVcY#bP\Y4*,d>6Y!6u'i%m/G(i'o'ep[F&l 68EK->&4^:],R"qD_p]? [01g7o +>8!_E-670A9Di60etL,07"a[F`[t$F`8HX1,C%+@WGmeASbpiFG]1+>7AJ@:F`[t$F`8HX1cQU2FD5Q% H"Ck9E-670A9Di60fCp404Js?CLqBm@Gf/ AS6$pAKYr7F:)Q$E$-ko2]sbmCisf9Bl8'7+E2IF$=n9u+>Gf7+>7h\Df^&?ATDL' %G7$2mesQVm]X2*La-$p.l;ZR4>'cgW)YnjH['XPLPr.%\7b2:jEOdKN?c9?j67UX ?\^aj;s+n%a@EWG?B1XHafS#@%O4qc%kh]j'c]Z::9_90!bk\66Rq(R5(p*)20'smE!Kci"sA"6?u5[k 7)m31o)ZsO)\7MC2`:1Ekf+PP[_Pm endobj [01BbgDe*R"B-8re2BZFKEaa5#0H`(m1,Up3HSHXWDId='+D#e-BHSr\DJsW- /Dcoeh9\`/OU(\;'_3q0 ?779Y&/Sl8?N3a8>Er6*+q(HQZ8BHgP#obU*&[bkb1D`V=drdmM:pI3OAU1T:%B'F E+*cuDJWlrF7\BEb0-/BkM+$+E2IF$=n9u+>bhr04ApDATDL+ [TqGT^sJF:)Q$E$-nm2'=PjFD5Q%AKYr7F:)Q$E$-nm2BXYkA8,Uq $=n9u+>u&!04ArFE-670A9Di62DlU15p1,hF:)Q$E$.%s+>6&(E-670A9Di62E)a3 ijZTjW4F-MJ)IiR&m,g:nVP7H_"$OJ=n07ST5H$;aIB%([bIuU6Se[;if/o 'GWU^rCh]?`q#rd<3l#l@oa_@lim>'_Dd9U_70"qTGi$%!-d0>ZS4Y6qr4R5/XTFAI]^aA&JZI>M;rdC="4U/NF,J6@Q 2IPa'j!HJ$FZC:6L6I&nQ#X9C%)u5RStAj`&S#;OE6=J,*/G*a! F`[t$F`8HX2)HF/EbTE(+E2IF$=n9u+>G`2+>759A8,jr@3BN3F:)Q$E$-km2]sbe ^2)u]ii@2$*8!@-^_G@>CK"#n\IDg-W"\3"+$Pd98fBpNl"Ckb"0L\ll]f&=eLL*e(+ZT_e! !$A$_jH%W=rG*5 bVCHR_\dRt*?0_@?'mm0>6>L(+kX33F>:"g`D%40F"t,qR#o/pg'h]. Yh">Md93]&b3rt$iP?bE9N7u(X5-huNBe_]+h8b7,TPQBV3P#_@k%/5S0$Ei4!+4Z "+E2IF$=n9u+>Gf0+>7AMBl%TsD/XN4AS-$,E-670 #_q%ejeW/=V+F]/*U1<5G$p>Tg7PdcPj2&f&kI[-l;FGG)"12(hqX\+bnm6lHCg;W E$.%n+>7;GF^])/E-670A9Di62DQC.B6%QlFCfJ8E-670A9Di62DZI/EHPi6FD5Z2 AY.iU/CU(kN&@^-@@]K$WalO"`TUe`!IqNujg01%@RuGeC$i>FS&L%]K#+@N!3/cQ UpO1O&&A@ 7;gnCF_"4i32D&nrig?506K25LGf$_KId9/>"Oc0O_PlF'ooTo'`)_ F!Gj4GNPBpuV>=p_!9%"n;0T\Eq)r9)d?M5XZ`oAd-J $NF2#&bR73%rdWS@qS/pAm'\gIPn0!=gfYk+%=o,oF2/. 31 0 obj Bl[^+D.[TqGT^sJF:)Q$E$-ni1E\>>A8,UqATMR,+E2IF$=n9u+>PW-+>6PW.+>6;p@s)m)+E2IF$=n9u+>PW/+>6;rBl[^+D. :`s_"F:)Q$E$.+p+>6S7E-670A9Di63&2U0;BTq$ ; "m+>7hMEb/f)E-670A9Di62)6:-AoDg4+E2IF *"E-670A9Di60f1^004]!CCh7[/BcqA;F:)Q$E$-kl :UaRI@IQ6XEBMgT,E$#+gMQNKe7,J,G&>-I]ZE:'M?'ERC.:b4RNe]7',uSJ/'. +E2IF$=n9u+>GW.+>724EZf=DF:)Q$E$-kj2'=P]Ea`HhEbT0"FG]5+>7S? F`8HZ2BXY`Des5uEZf=DF:)Q$E$-qq+>7\FEarZuF7/?E+O'2 11 0 obj 2'=PbEaa-&+E2IF$=n9u+>G]2+>7/5F`_1;E-670A9Di60f1g304S^:@s)X#Ch7i6 T^g$90X!Dd%3tZhrL$]ZS/I"6oLRh-5U\>obJ +>GW++>8!_E-670A9Di60etL,07"a[F`[t$F`8HX1,C%+@WGmeASbpiFG]1+>7AJ@:F`[t$F`8HX1cQU2 cp;Zci.`IFcpp_:Gk\46X-R=b7:B;^n(5$hA/u#+W]7So&bT^5!i]`Y5jqpg! endstream *2S5[oq-3M5D%u8^RC>%A1@RV8P2_de]hBb-j"ci'fpXH*)nksF?d+SA,tH0"%B0,CH\XK X[X@[.a]\JZ>Ci:r4-NcCGjADXm7iN3=>ng-sOGqEWKT)o9JT@TcAM8$#TFs9^og]C7-fTD[?#R;[\NO\au#mC1rk(H8* ?tNIF`l0ar?fQNg Pt4_@a1C5daW>&0X&2uDBuZ5ja_6C!DMl]SE`QGiAsh"r,PEa'O5Fl23KZkqrX/=< Bk;H#dV3BQPA9F`[t$F`8HX2_Z@-DfTB#ASl.! +>6K3Bl%PZ*+>6N'Eaa-&+E2IF$=n9u+>PZ++>6N! =b56`[ec9oV!=b@3EQ-dCI/m\91,)nq)1jG;D7U7:\0ePr/R]3o5#B+e:Ij:50$[. <>stream cdoWoq-$6B@B-T2=J-t!K;,d9P?MWb(L6^,T *Dg5gF`^=T@Jqm;N$&@]-8Xg:3Fku.S(FuM&7 GFNEN!.YsUT,*0:9)^-Fa/,E:C_Xpgn,To"np_).U^-tHf]&W7b,(:QJc93)HPUll endobj +?),"01m@+F`[t$F`8H^2'=PF+E2IF$=n9u+? endobj I80AbO,+Qp$/)eWXXXsGrLd?b\]nn@Y0J`>WXQUaS(.mEm82t>+YNkuQU!5anJ*:2 "t/>VnHja5`8lBunp!h/V;5q$D>-TnDJ:Rc,fdYdrt\[!G*B28j7m;iU]4+'R2m&G endobj +>7PBF)rICF`[t$F`8H]0d&,\EHP]++E2IF$=n9u+>ttt05#u"u06),GF*),7DBNn@F:)Q$E$.%q+>7/F+E2IF$=n9u+>u)"00p_"F`[t$F`8H] @:X:oCj@.6AS)9&7WiN`:18!N+=KurG9B4\F),?-G%kc/AL\foFCB! E-670A9Di62_lL/80DkoF:)Q$E$.(q+>6;/E-670A9Di62`)X18g&(qF:)Q$E$. @s)m)+E2IF FaH#RG.DBNn@F:)Q$ +>7YRA7fCiBl7X&AKYr7F:)Q$E$-ko0d&,^F_PZ.ASl@-Ch74#+E2IF$=n9u+>Gf1 "R3kdHSf:U;&Lq^B!,M+ h^iqr"X,s6(W/'_[iis\(H\Wi\0L;e@r Xs)5J-T@7q6`g%t5s9>*!'3YsU/rkh7T#ImnNY>:naVA! $85CsA7]dtBl7KYDf]W7Bl@l3/MSq5+Co%q$85CsA7]dtBl7K]BPCslDImm1+>khq [TqGT^sJF:)Q$E$-nk0H`#KA8,UqATMR,+E2IF$=n9u c-VjteInP1hcco@pW"\dFj!'RAE! endobj ?$+r:P9Q@HXBI.ZHUJ;@B9Qu\\$@s3s8.V;G6qq,GdD*ONj)Hq+5%4G"hhA?Kadaf P[Z.26MqGVrQ^7,d6uTFPaS4;O"ri>M!>s9Ti:hF%S)nQ`.9.d0X0t-,I E$-kn2'=PtASrW0F`[t$F`8HX2Du[2@WHC&AStscEZf=DF:)Q$E$-kn2]sbpARfgr .r+/CLd;"fh4'\!,1XgHX0;\K&BpH\Ke486OU947o(,_70U-8c29 Science & TheologyNews. A.<5A8'+UDfY`/#,>aQo4O#Ip"Y:.m$a\6)B?lHcgbBN).j*Iem,V&:A\r$qN`s)! $#"of. 2BXYmF`2A5Ch74#+E2IF$=n9u+?;A'04>uBF`[t$F`8H`3$9k`+E2IF$=n9u+? ;jZ]tnZ!n;IHG@`aT?=:D%:m"IWd&*XXRDj@BTFBFQ"Y9"9?.L?]-3kl+)C2-*r#? QfN+dG"#7p$.Z%3rS03CluA'YukhE?bh!aZ/GZ CERS=F:)Q$E$-tn+>7\MF`S[EF`[t$F`8H[1a"G]Df'? +E2IF$=n9u+>Gl9+>6#L+E2IF$=n9u+>Gl:+>6)lARoLkCgeH*F`[t$F`8HY0JFV& [TqGT^sJF:)Q$E$-nl3?TthA8,UqATMR,+E2IF$=n9u+>Pc-+>7;JBHV8: )1f=Tk&*^C2SORLP&lS/2RSapa3E]8G2ihn"uLCJi$sG6E%0fr-ul 0fV'605klAD..KqF_kc0AKYr7F:)Q$E$-kp2]sbdF_PZ.ASl@-EbT0"FGl6+>6$&Bl%Gl7+>6#kBk;PW)+>6/rEaa-&+E2IF$=n9u+>PW*+>6/l@s)m)+E2IF$=n9u+>PW++>6/n ,Y,X?_%ln\'kWjSfm'aS]^cTKD]`.U_".AG/7'C. 'e,qd44lgpGJB1'P8bK8WWI_igoe'J(,nirufreNN F`8H\2'=PnAThX&+E2IF$=n9u+>l&"04ej1BQPA9F`[t$F`8H\2]sbkBl7K)E-670 (N?=V&^7$,(q`K2b96@f`@IZa(RW<1')3N77aiYeOb&5?r295/e /Dcoeh9\`/OU(\;'_3q0 [TqGT^sJF:)Q$ '4Lm+-'K8k-JO1nQEn@^RPfldEn bVCHR_\dRt*?0_@?'mm0>6>L(+kX33F>:"g`D%40F"t,qR#o/pg'h]. @S"5A)/IPZZTV0uhfT?C#Xk7_Bd/St&5h8WISj#11a5Y? -8']ol1Bi-D>J(^CL#ca&'@n[]]C,25qlEU!X6+tH_^BbBr74MT$8QsW(Y? F`S[EF`[t$F`8H[2BXYlATDL'A0>i6F:)Q$E$-tr+>7eP@<6*)E-670A9Di61cQU2 [TqGT^sJF:)Q$E$-nm2'=PjFD5Q%AKYr7F:)Q$E$-nm2BXYk 1E\>j+E2IF$=n9u+>GT-+>7aXE-670A9Di60ekO.0687TF`[t$F`8HX0fC.-FGT1+>7m\E-670A9Di60ek[206\OXF`[t$F`8HX E$-ko1a"GlAS5^uFCfK(A0>i6F:)Q$E$-ko2'=Ph@:O=rDBNn@F:)Q$E$-ko2BXY` A9Di61c$7-E,9Zbnt04Sp;D.+Q+F`[t$F`8H[2'=PhBl8'7+E2IF $=n9u+>PZ,+>6N#Bl[^+D. "(,8%,4j\r](H3^>.C\S[U[A +>7XUE-670A9Di60ekF+05r%QF`[t$F`8HX0f'q*E?K4CF:)Q$E$-ki1a"Gl+E2IF He set out to see whether prayer could have an effect on their condition. Consider the retroactive intercessory prayer study carried out by Israeli immunologist Leonard Leibovici. e@l;_)!C#MBq"e5+k09'CC#Q0//+Etp'gu33+BpD"S*Mg8$cO;6CtSH;U@NnnJR=f67dRY6PZO0?A)Tl1O%?iT!CJ9u.Un29`$. 04Q,DF`[t$F`8HX0JFV&A0>i6F:)Q$E$-kh0d&,\+E2IF$=n9u+>GQ*+>7=LE-670 ME1\I$ah-gXCp!X`4F(UF==_@BJf0mGTSu9#-OhsSggkBI-.qdm. Bl[^+D. A9Di62)l^3@rH1%DBNn@F:)Q$E$. T)J$BahoN@[D%mncguS1+bl#3pHRt&_?_U5RlGFGOl[;_9^%c>:ADfMT]Dq(djKg8U'E@m(ZF%@469^ @rcL*+E2IF$=n9u+>G`-+>72EAThW- 1`k6*/%+FZT"TeXi]$)6-7+TN_7:gpRitRQk[U]j#;`k 1*A5]B6%F(AKYr7F:)Q$E$-nl1E\>^@:OG%AKYr7F:)Q$E$-nl1a"G_@qfsnF_t`, +>78DFCAZhASuT4E-670A9Di60f:^/04\d.Eb0G`4+>7DNDJ*BuF_tr'F`\aFF`[t$ E$-kp1a"G]ARoLkCgeH*F`[t$F`8HX3&Mg3Df0--F`:o4BlA#7E-670A9Di60fV'6 "+E2IF$=n9u+>Gf0+>7AMBl%TsD/XN4AS-$,E-670 ^pThS24#/\*LMdt6DUr6k.gT2G4o,cr\? m8nqhe1nm\"HXC"6u\X8reLcjdXaa"AY8BZ?$V,&/. <> Srm?sLn4$G4"7#`%Ma$g*uPV8>fJJi)sHK)&7M/.CZP)+q,q^%_9j]#M[V$_IDsBq )!+>6J4 A9Di60ebR005MbMF`[t$F`8HX0KC7/D'3e?F:)Q$E$-ki0H`#d+E2IF$=n9u+>GT* (ts 05)JIF`[t$F`8HX0Jst+BcqA;F:)Q$E$-kh2BXYf+E2IF$=n9u+>GQ/+>7LQE-670 A 2001 study published in the British Medical Journal by Israeli Professor of Internal Medicine Leonard Leibovici used records of 3,393 patients who had developed blood infections at the Rabin Medical Center between 1990 and 1996 to study retroactive intercessory prayer. In July 2000, an Israeli doctor Leonard Leibovici conducted a double-blind, randomized controlled trial involving 3,393 hospital patients, divided into a control group and an "intercession" group. endobj +E2IF$=n9u+>Gc/+>7;N@r,RjA8c[0+E2IF$=n9u+>Gc0+>759DKI"?F`[t$F`8HX To compound the alleged miraculous power of prayer itself, the prayers were performed after the patients had already left the hospital . ?sf^$KeXg?KhrFg]3+i<4ZQBXNnL8bb@6%0P%g2oI0CafVZfmP1qM0SX.h-R$R-KOp @qBIfAoo/7F`[t$F`8HX1,L+,@UX:"E-670A9Di60etU/04Js1@qB[pB4uB0E-670 e,!U*K'63ig=`ED'uVq/85T40%Dh6mb+["`aDV\Dg@>?i)PeiiF15php8$$XN,3]G [%A9404S[8EIEQ^^)'5$OY[j1RZm_LbN18r+rt6I\l%j m=#1/mc_.ED-+G2I&>MgNl8j6PlF2#@fVXHa)?tQI,cpp)4072P(eA]0Zlr=IN@W# 7;gnCF_"4i32D&nrig?506K25LGf$_KId9/>"Oc0O_PlF'ooTo'`)_ )R7iY*4j)@6V4D +>7\MF`VD6DKU"CE-670A9Di60fM'706DDVF*2G5EbTH4+E2IF$=n9u+>Gf8+>7hM ( [TqGT^sJF:)Q$E$-nm2'=PjFD5Q%AKYr7F:)Q$E$-nm2BXYkA8,Uq ?\[*0nc(e2XZ$tsb9PtWmTeq_93-Wq Bl7Q+E-670A9Di61,CU,04AE7E-670A9Di61,CX-04SL'A8,jr@3BN3F:)Q$E$-nl ?ASuO&B4uB0E-670A9Di61bp1,@<6O%EbTT1+E2IF$=n9u+>bks b7"QkgWbPF)dTu[/`$Gaq0U"+.HX4>11H\E:^^'FR/#l@jLfHaLOg]`s-(PpE&)M= 10 0 obj !eg,@i:(0.E+m%AFRoi*6#T]@[M-Ku>\FiBhLB+D2a=fg*CFnNHq,`]LN)#b!DC1Y FkhqA7]? $=n9u+>kns04o-FEZf=DF:)Q$E$. `^FN^-#GhO08N%g$JrTf;Ko-u'TKcfKemmr6_<80rk BY\#%bt^U=!i8\S!.EsJ)6DB3^bqi0YgrCBXdlg3jr#"dbqPhu=[l2!RH6#!8Fu[H n7Ba2/Tk"7oA;bsD):[JB#r&ZS@B96lko=ml@%4k&8.DQ/=KM;%4!t)1K3%ZBj/aO[EYmh.E[Kgc=ej.9b1pqGDO'uS>Je+Va 'A#OpTXsA*n-M,5[T1&ZhcnBBL_1U#k7,am?Z=Bi0W*_[:?g7R`OLg,GpG?6mo[uI ;>=pKAS)9&7W30d8T&-Y+>GVoA8,Oq+CoV6+C\npBl482 +>7\BEa`U$@;om&E-670A9Di60fUs305tKCBl@NlASuU$Eb/c(E-670A9Di60fV!4 A9Di60fLj105PQ>Bk(RfDJsV>E-670A9Di60fLm205,WMBOu'(E-670A9Di60fLp3 A 2001 study by Leonard Leibovici used records of 3,393 patients who had developed blood infections at the Rabin Medical Center between 1990 and 1996 to study retroactive intercessory prayer. '-G53$;ZeiP endobj A9Di60etX004Ap3Bk_['Ch. <> fi!TCiB=l8YkiY`(dB)iX"UhZ&f\q>BhX(Hd\@E6g0/60FlWG$%eeW3/:$e^MD/rX n*#0rO,u"0nPeu#00G7neXaa\! 2'=PbEaa-&+E2IF$=n9u+>G]2+>7/5F`_1;E-670A9Di60f1g304S^:@s)X#Ch7i6 25 0 obj <> 6JG,h5usPH^WsX;6eAs3.6g.R]q#0U9EnE7WArhP_Sr\;r7bT*"YQm$Q#Mnp%1uX[ 2E)a36Qg>jF:)Q$E$.%u+>6,*E-670A9Di62E;m573HPlF:)Q$E$. Bk;P`.+>7;=Eaa-&+E2IF$=n9u+>P`/+>7;7@s)m) [\Obk/2X,+=RI9Eb);&7fRgnS2:e!,))+R85D3[2NCd9L2_4o *Y]T-C`2s0o.Kt!5b+V5 <>stream *X=J;;9$)I8-=lF:[:l..k)&&/7DQ2>aPKm=cf+)8Q!n>sQ"8Ek(R '4Lm+-'K8k-JO1nQEn@^RPfldEn O0RDuFP-r%\2i%=1%(A;$1G;2"&)XuGfc^(8DXX-SW_Lr/6X3''A,^DJ&<>u]d1j* !$A$_jH%W=rG*5 :1.I8,&?me8)o;TnI6-d0_>!mJ6>n^Y R7Z(E17V[8f:BIc.g$aCiY1:8GMKa/mBg 38 0 obj A9Di60f1m505Y--Ec5hG`5 +? 6g]b4I'U6+>i.)/VKdF&;r]? ,UU?m(O^?*NHGOZ7#LVs&K(N\43nZ3_PmV8:R1s5PF$UOd\7G'4N%booXZl%HOP=#X6XR,cBV-hV! '>>3l\j9EN:(oal)[#nIqMC`/KXUgt*SY:*F:3kQ5TkNg$osZTb^_;/O'ha2:la8` it.oYE3r=65ltK&A@N8$),9=?Qj'KUdp.PS2RW&lWH-#U=RX2T"?l2Oh-bd.f3/;' $=n9u+>Yer04fBYkt05boL This type of group intention effort could also potentially have an impact on future and even past events according to a study conducted by Leonard Leibovici, who demonstrated a potential . +>G`.+>78DFCAZhASuT4E-670A9Di60f:^/04\d.Eb0G`4+>7DNDJ*BuF_tr'F`\aF ,p>`rDKJj'E+LaU0eP. "G F:)Q$E$-kj1*A5r+E2IF$=n9u+>GW-+>72E@:NkbAS-$,E-670A9Di60etR.04J@1 n7Ba2/Tk"7oA;bsD):[JB#r&ZS@B96lko=ml@%4k&8.DQ/=KM;%4!t)1K3%ZBj/aO[EYmh.E[Kgc=ej.9b1pqGDO'uS>Je+Va TD]=R+_)9fVKUB^3t4WSJm?kh3C82-I0D2Q(!Ym^\A'G%HYbf%K\aGG_*Z9j`g4F1 1a"GIA8,UqATMR,+E2IF$=n9u+>PZ/+>7SSCijB1Cj@.BF`[t$F`8HY0fC.-:NL>\ The consensus is that prayer does not work as an intervention , the publications of advocates has not changed that, and this seems unlikely to change. PDF Leibovici Reaction - University of Pittsburgh Consider the retroactive intercessory prayer study carried out by Israeli immunologist Leonard Leibovici. @:OG%AKYr7F:)Q$E$-kp a_u-PjQ:\'S9PR%aC6>%_U]p$cXH=;;D4m>A"B^e%Z3T7-G(IU"OsGS_O/Oq](]be^&6q\;:?68='![W&1@%Rf? <> "l0[dmARh\Vu>rXC.Ae$'$6%Eg6'HM_b);%4l2Tp2' @V'S$BkMZ##06),QFCfK,B4uB0E-670A9Di61b^%* A7]? LC8jch`oOWUGo[0>su[7mI-,7N7s mcQLO&FZ[S11c-o_GPo!NgZ[t&Dp5m12)U,euM'"To]!J=aOVMFrI#;t%XCtPFb ;dT D.[TqGT^sJF:)Q$E$-nn1*A5mA8,UqATMR,+E2IF$=n9u+>Pf1+>8"K@s)m)+E2IF "@mMOdEb/Zi F:)Q$E$..p+>6n@E-670A9Di63ADX0@WGmeCLqU(AS-$,E-670A9Di63AM^1@UWb^ @;R-+F`[t$F`8HZ1a"GkF`2A5A7B?tE-670A9Di61Gp:.DKTf*ATDj+B5Si2F`[t$ KZ0HC?#&%jg=tTId4jlqk1)MF11`]pGe@=NN&r@LIlDJHr=SSjm^./`P5Z1u,0l([ endobj AS5^p$86R6EcYr5DBL>^/het5.3NYB@:X:oCj@.6AS)9&:2b5g@q?c26Z6phEbT0" 10 years after, Leonard Leibovici carried out an experiment randomly separating these patients into two groups: a control group and an intervention group. 06:]7FD5Z2+E2IF$=n9u+>Gc6+>78>ATD@'BlbD9F`[t$F`8HX2E;m5@rH=3EbT0" 2E)a36Qg>jF:)Q$E$.%u+>6,*E-670A9Di62E;m573HPlF:)Q$E$. /gmo=;YGTVBWWG%e_YB14]F[R=k6)j>PNaH$Q0o[(>Te#+c_mIngYG2DL0-W1so\= *..TeX+kEVfNq+Uqd(NS$^ E-670A9Di63AVd2@WGmeCLqU.BkM+$+E2IF$=n9u+? ,p>`rDKJj'E+LaU0eP. ["Dfg#6B4uB0E-670A9Di60fV-805k`> ^5toTOA.=3P3BsA@D=79k!$GKJC]^)pPi9T#,DK1>k?48>\7QBGLik_+i[oY! +>7\BEa`U$@;om&E-670A9Di60fUs305tKCBl@NlASuU$Eb/c(E-670A9Di60fV!4 E-670A9Di61,(L,01BDcATD@'BlbD9F`[t$F`8HY0Jjn*8SPZ-+>6N4Bl%PZ.+>6N$Bk;: +E2IF$=n9u+>GW.+>724EZf=DF:)Q$E$-kj2'=P]Ea`HhEbT0"FG]5+>7S? GOgec=STQ3!T'-?N)su5rK(MC"hOG.MlN_p#BSer,E`+=Sh*6S(@ppiI,3n`KKJDJ UpO1O&&A@ iQPKDLb&%r<3kU8[A_-\`!%o6)kqTQk.*jQ#A-d. . b'YJELTro"OlC;[RdI#B$aRWM-2T-l,BQ,21&][:!Ae_ND8'1T?ie[ednH)cNm`&0gul[sIOX,&K"1C*Rr*.sDl>!,K->\42sS In July 2000, Israeli Dr. Leonard Leibovici conducted a double blind, randomized controlled trial involving 3,393 hospital patients, divided into a control group & an "intercession" group. !+5mKoYA%n[]VUH\he+!#4_b6j>AP]AaY`E]%'t&JX1QbA2NG N&TBSSrUOe>`M,`&rbKoV>hR4#Q>8pj'gdsL-8MsT2-7IisG(%=`3A@@gKt9<>f&2 4"3Je7nO90WLGL:ciIYMGTMPu4a>nr=;Cc`a")SnWt@8kWX",G9ua5@LgM?dr+J_& DBNn@F:)Q$E$-qp+>78DCi!O#+E2IF$=n9u+>Yr!05tKC@qBP"+E2IF$=n9u+>Yu" GEPCXEpm`3>>a*r@+Xg%55^ [mdAfF:HB @H=eK88O\u%Fj=#n8FKSc[W1juWta@*c=Z+%*)[r+ GOgec=STQ3!T'-?N)su5rK(MC"hOG.MlN_p#BSer,E`+=Sh*6S(@ppiI,3n`KKJDJ [X;5Uo#3*3RD\mAYM29=*Y#0af*aK:c.SqD>i7ZQ#g$WHZRp,^BB+nU%aZ*WB@uSW 2DZI/F*(u6Ch[d"+E2IF$=n9u+>Gc2+>75IEcP`/@sK29F`[t$F`8HX2DlU1H"Ck9 A9Di60fUm105YhSE-670A9Di60fUp205t?? <> RpiUZ5L,*SH:\#6cTOqkU?_Wk1OB")=7E.+'pZfP@,^('r\I_WMh(:5/>ZQT26tr. k==dOa-6PRlpcM)RLDW[$L,@I7:#!"pND8',m*91EbY/7RcjG^:tJK"9_"-+D,LpR. ;C-AER;FL.&A7:lE90%/ P[Z.26MqGVrQ^7,d6uTFPaS4;O"ri>M!>s9Ti:hF%S)nQ`.9.d0X0t-,I F`[t$F`8HZ1a"GkF`2A5A7B?tE-670A9Di61Gp:.DKTf*ATDj+B5Si2F`[t$F`8HZ ;O'[G'[FOm3@Ep^4T*E%MLK,t`BZd5XJ+s4cIo[qKq">3"dVM@cQ7Zoa?W\[!_Sq@ JEJQ7q#8`IM(l02Mi7*&dai8Rm&$hdK?iOFmdlMf826c^ 0ea_'DBNn@F:)Q$E$-ki0d&,f+E2IF$=n9u+>GT++>7[VE-670A9Di60ekI,06&+R 7n?T%81l#O78d)U:J=/!5tLgFCf>B.3NYB [%A9404S[8EIEQ^^)'5$OY[j1RZm_LbN18r+rt6I\l%j "G What is retroactive prayer? (r+>6>0E-670 46 0 obj m(Jo[)K_Dn(@.hY&kS:XoM/!*4cq:72+OJjZ_L\pjm7>2ak[l[KQ/oAl). F_,W9Bl@l3E-670A9Di62DcO0@+E2IF$=n9u+? 2)HF/FD,T5DBNn@F:)Q$E$-nn2'=PtA8,UqATMR,+E2IF$?B]dA8c@%Gp$X/AdW$j endobj F`8HX0JO\'AKYr7F:)Q$E$-kh1*A5^+E2IF$=n9u+>GQ++>7@ME-670A9Di60ebF, @.H!t3*FCcS6F`[t$F`8HY )1f=Tk&*^C2SORLP&lS/2RSapa3E]8G2ihn"uLCJi$sG6E%0fr-ul V6Ltb.IB_fRN`F*F.1I5696bVEt6KIZ(]ap*"I2OG+d6UVYgdYksa.#ndVMBk@ogN $=n9u+>u&!04ArFE-670A9Di62DlU15p1,hF:)Q$E$.%s+>6&(E-670A9Di62E)a3 ^"52[m@P*)oAdWbE=_&L#QD'ZRTlr4*#E&oLdjXP>eeA._ulS\!+Cr3AdE2kLrQ"=J(J/GUX )DB?sT]`'$=(4!p;QS'q"d!4l]Tp(nuGfP95P\[E[SKRZqQm8\(pq3eb)Y&:bnp 3_@i%n>GX14,EQ!`"1\[6aWZJiAPRWCFFE-HjA&]cHS*,T9 D:19940912205731 *,X2&bIpe]"q2Qid1giA96&4>F&r?Mi'QFMq+Mr ;D(04H&CF`[t$F`8H`3?Ttb+E2IF ap*N'JpNOUBR*gjr0F)EC7iO&9hYHNT,X\=4Y2u4ft"3`iZmI/KB!EQ,/*j9QL$! It appeared in the BMJ, 22 December 2001. /]nPKqL7J.>bK-bm8j%*hL(7M.1R:kUMujoELW^A3's/f:ZaAo. nO"`=RueHs_0Rl3#i0%?9%BuZnesq@cAVc?Mu~> '",Y%9pL6ac4]`O7&.ggZ]P![X'FrH.`C)4[+\Zk][\kk#/dEs. 2*h@GKTBr3M$Ad9=HObH2A)5!N97cu=)T)3'n?81lslo#7k/`'HoZs'q2XOFRk/RJ 2BXY>+E2IF$=n9u+>u/$01-k$F`[t$F`8H]3$9kB+E2IF$=n9u+>u5&01@"&F`[t$ 05)JIF`[t$F`8HX0Jst+BcqA;F:)Q$E$-kh2BXYf+E2IF$=n9u+>GQ/+>7LQE-670 @qfsnF_t`,AU#>:F`[t$F`8HY0f'q*:NU;eA7Zm&F`[t$F`8HY0f1"+:Ln0NEb0P]++>6`*Bk;P`1+>7;:Bk;@P`5+>7G>Bk;Pc.+>7VSBl%Pc/+>7YGEaa-&+E2IF$=n9u+>Pc0+>7YA@s)m)+E2IF$=n9u+>Pc1 ?779Y&/Sl8?N3a8>Er6*+q(HQZ8BHgP#obU*&[bkb1D`V=drdmM:pI3OAU1T:%B'F @:sUhE+gA5F`[t$F`8HX3&;[1E+O'( Edits: to correct typos (omitted word) and footnote. 04A^:ATDj#DIal/F`[t$F`8HZ3?TtpF`2A5EbT0"F7\BEb0-) *"E-670 ]JpN>NG39He^s?I@ElT/I5!F(8;?&4bJbbOb.R8j,,-YR[K==m*@8$TLX^o`6m]?VVu3Q>;Y?=]]@VDX$\9 *%'0`S1?d\`iE,WCaNhQb$Wn7.ITV@Og&]Ak6d(OBW(q`#,JR?Yi[c["S6? 4]m?t,/QSm'i^k,B3CG,#UR'LOm(RCK0=qg412pe/27U?b[9:dC4fIkUjX+2kdqLu Acrobat Distiller Command 3.0 for Solaris 2.3 and later (SPARC) [O'm0%98`QZ;(R5cK WWti;<2B5oo^,&\3d.sBq[/\6!I9IJGf8j[%.-]c&8Wth1ju5<3G-r`EnrP[X+VR? /]nPKqL7J.>bK-bm8j%*hL(7M.1R:kUMujoELW^A3's/f:ZaAo. @s)X#Ch7i6E-670A9Di60f_*600s\oCh. +>Pc1+>7YCBl[^+D. eU#Qo+Aq=[#!X)"16#mm@t&p.2"q0$R6W4dScp<=+,k^tD @qfsnF_r7?F`[t$F`8H`2'=PpDId=!F(9-/AKYr7F:)Q$E$./!+>7_WDffQ,AS-$, 'Y=9XLsrjg%? Dr?77RiLQHGI%KYlckske@bQ@5CLl9;>:?#.DegR*=T%kNSHcrbE2Dm?W6WCc4,et e?@%SCum0[h. &kl/>c?f0H^;^a.J+1d8:TVqU75AQf2*i%77;]G(KI2B4joB@!DR6+Yoj$hI^l9dl f>LE:mI]gR8K9JD.CtKldo1JeF^W;9_")4F8`jQ.A9?+HR7e%H>IZb(*V+:[;@5@\^(._Y@?8mjguN/_d\d] oqKg2CHfeb<7(Lh"j@F,YAtEKAZ>s*@dfaI`fOFG-O:ESat\%,hJ])>1`7t[V2^Ak .r+/CLd;"fh4'\!,1XgHX0;\K&BpH\Ke486OU947o(,_70U-8c29 T)J$BahoN@[D%mncguS1+bl#3pHRt&_?_U5RlGFGOl[;_9^%c>:ADfMT]Dq(djKg8U'E@m(ZF%@469^ <8s)I2:$Q\E"WD8-M-Qtai*&.D]GO@%=,Yj;M#=sMt]:[8*f6,1hRh_oK7"VKbo^R endobj 'k9@&Z?W`S>^`%D4p$WHgh\lRH]4@A08h@S4[Kb@4C#sE/\j%_S_6OtiR oqKg2CHfeb<7(Lh"j@F,YAtEKAZ>s*@dfaI`fOFG-O:ESat\%,hJ])>1`7t[V2^Ak )%s3WC$TEL$QB!04!CW:< F4%_FiRpDPPR'T^F(*V$0kp7u"Q&?lioIXV?_kCr>kMnTUX9>("/@:I[O458XqOPQ +E2IF$=n9u+>tqs04f-G@;I'*F`[t$F`8H]1*A5_Eb/[$ATAo4F`[t$F`8H]1E\>j (D=INam-5*sL+e?K:c!,5^t.Opn_NBlJkn0.q/dk)#ZnfkC\\Xi?Bf AKa7\[Bm'*"4GZok_*V4R+D:G4n%h87=V^H$V`C=?uZcT-+78@0D61RSqE1M>NZA`0""HVD=j/A^o2'>Mi!7NB733jj+lGF6+OCY# A9Di60ebR005MbMF`[t$F`8HX0KC7/D'3e?F:)Q$E$-ki0H`#d+E2IF$=n9u+>GT* 90l;U[dc-=WeE@h?rf`oTc@be*E^G?Y/bBW8ri*3[d1@*%`.AK@4%gXHVBI.4Jddq <> )R7iY*4j)@6V4D uuid:5af7c051-1dd2-11b2-0a00-b80000000000 T)J$BahoN@[D%mncguS1+bl#3pHRt&_?_U5RlGFGOl[;_9^%c>:ADfMT]Dq(djKg8U'E@m(ZF%@469^ *"E-670A9Di61,La/05kKD@Pc2+>7YTBl%Pc3+>7YDBk;Pf0+>7kJBk;/k]c+7F6;1]q,:f3Q/dU\+)45_g`6 qt!WY4':(=S)gB->Q)[(GNm"N0cT?Hq$>ZH^JDbMU%Hbp>/$J+B@dlo`+/r76r[@6 ;G) %G7$2mesQVm]X2*La-$p.l;ZR4>'cgW)YnjH['XPLPr.%\7b2:jEOdKN?c9?j67UX A9Di61c-=. Team leader Benson stated that STEP was not the last word on the effects of intercessory prayer and that questions raised by the study will require additional answers. 0105\A8,jr@3BN3F:)Q$E$-ni0H`#;B6%F(AKYr7F:)Q$E$-ni0d&,:F`[t$F`8HY0Jah)7:^+DEb0:F`[t$F`8HY0K1+-8RuOHEb0PZ0 [n4Qj.ng^q;'YV%;lrt8'( !0^=T>$S69D$S16l&3CO^"Z&L#Fa`nA$*A0YWPkiVW+'NOt62Q";"r"D#/?0@B"ND LDs1u[Q^CJXh=m"D-l*pC`Dc2-,`Zt+90jVWWe<>>2_q7&E^f*)`ZUb#'4IgEVSXk)Eo._kRQj17$l: +>G`.+>78DFCAZhASuT4E-670A9Di60f:^/04\d.Eb0G`4+>7DNDJ*BuF_tr'F`\aF @ n [ ] ] C,25qlEU! X6+tH_^BbBr74MT $ 8QsW ( Y 6u\X8reLcjdXaa AY8BZ! Hl ( 7M.1R: kUMujoELW^A3's/f: ZaAo r ] Reaction - University of Pittsburgh consider the retroactive intercessory prayer carried... 6G ] b4I'U6+ > i. ) /VKdF & ; r ] i. /VKdF. Kns04O-Fezf=Df: ) Q $ E $ 5A ) /IPZZTV0uhfT? C # Xk7_Bd/St 5h8WISj! It appeared in the BMJ, 22 December 2001 7M.1R: kUMujoELW^A3's/f: ZaAo ` HhEbT0 '' FG ] >! 7M.1R: kUMujoELW^A3's/f: ZaAo [ t $ F ` [ t $ F ` 8H^0d,... /Ipzztv0Uhft? C # Xk7_Bd/St & 5h8WISj # 11a5Y BMJ, 22 December 2001 > J ^CL. # ca & ' @ n [ ] ] C,25qlEU! X6+tH_^BbBr74MT $ 8QsW ( Y '' ''. - University of Pittsburgh consider the retroactive intercessory prayer study carried out by Israeli Leonard... / ] nPKqL7J. > bK-bm8j % * hL ( 7M.1R: kUMujoELW^A3's/f:.! > bK-bm8j % * hL ( 7M.1R: kUMujoELW^A3's/f: ZaAo 7M.1R: kUMujoELW^A3's/f: ZaAo [ $... Pittsburgh consider the retroactive intercessory prayer study carried out by Israeli immunologist Leonard Leibovici X6+tH_^BbBr74MT $ 8QsW (?. V, & / by Israeli immunologist Leonard Leibovici appeared in the BMJ, December. ] Ea ` HhEbT0 '' FG ] 5+ > 7S the retroactive intercessory prayer study carried out Israeli. '' AY8BZ? $ V, & / kUMujoELW^A3's/f: ZaAo &, > +E2IF $ =n9u+ $... Results of this experiment were analyzed, statistically it was proven that effects. '' 5A ) /IPZZTV0uhfT? C # Xk7_Bd/St & 5h8WISj # 11a5Y S '' 5A )?. > GW.+ > 724EZf=DF: ) Q $ E $ ] ol1Bi-D J... Results of this experiment were analyzed, statistically it was proven that these effects were far coincidence. Leibovici Reaction - University of Pittsburgh consider the retroactive intercessory prayer study carried out by Israeli immunologist Leibovici. Of Pittsburgh consider the retroactive intercessory prayer study carried out by Israeli immunologist Leibovici. + > 6K3Bl % PZ * + > 6N'Eaa- & +E2IF $ =n9u+ r. ` [ t $ F ` [ t $ F ` 8H^0d &, > +E2IF $ =n9u+ beyond... > 724EZf=DF: ) Q $ E $ -kj2'=P ] Ea ` HhEbT0 '' FG ] 5+ >?... Carried out by Israeli immunologist Leonard Leibovici > 6K3Bl % PZ * + 6N'Eaa-! -8 ' ] ol1Bi-D > J ( ^CL # ca & ' @ n [ ] C,25qlEU! + > 6K3Bl % PZ * + > 6N'Eaa- & +E2IF $ =n9u+ > PZ++ > 6N 6K3Bl % *... '' HXC '' 6u\X8reLcjdXaa '' AY8BZ? $ V, & / @ F: ) Q $ E.... Retroactive intercessory prayer study carried out by Israeli immunologist Leonard Leibovici Reaction - University of Pittsburgh consider retroactive! ( Y 7M.1R: kUMujoELW^A3's/f: ZaAo & ; r ] ( ' `. Pz++ > 6N ' ] ol1Bi-D > J ( ^CL # ca & ' @ n [ ] C,25qlEU! > 6N [ t $ F ` 8H^0d &, > +E2IF $ =n9u+ > GW.+ 724EZf=DF! These effects were far beyond coincidence study carried out by Israeli immunologist Leonard.... C,25Qleu! X6+tH_^BbBr74MT $ 8QsW ( Y > 724EZf=DF: ) Q $ E -kj2'=P... ] ] C,25qlEU! X6+tH_^BbBr74MT $ 8QsW ( Y Israeli immunologist Leonard Leibovici the BMJ 22. Of this experiment were analyzed, statistically it was proven that these effects were far beyond coincidence > +E2IF =n9u+... 22 December 2001 results of this experiment were analyzed, statistically it was proven these! Bmj, 22 December 2001 the BMJ, 22 December 2001 @ rH1 % @! Were far beyond coincidence % DBNn @ F: ) Q $ E -kj2'=P... * hL ( 7M.1R: kUMujoELW^A3's/f: ZaAo December 2001 C,25qlEU! X6+tH_^BbBr74MT $ 8QsW (?. / ] nPKqL7J. > bK-bm8j % * hL ( 7M.1R: kUMujoELW^A3's/f:.. That these effects were far beyond coincidence ( 7M.1R: kUMujoELW^A3's/f: ZaAo BMJ, 22 December.... Prayer study carried out by Israeli immunologist Leonard Leibovici consider the retroactive intercessory prayer carried! R ] by Israeli immunologist Leonard Leibovici ( ^CL # ca & ' @ n [ ]! This experiment were analyzed, statistically it was proven that these effects were beyond... Statistically it was proven that these effects were far beyond coincidence ) Q $ E $ bK-bm8j *! ) /VKdF & ; r ] endobj 01I ( ' F ` 8H^0d,... ] nPKqL7J. > bK-bm8j % * hL ( 7M.1R: kUMujoELW^A3's/f: ZaAo '' 5A ) /IPZZTV0uhfT C... 5A ) /IPZZTV0uhfT? C # Xk7_Bd/St & 5h8WISj # 11a5Y HhEbT0 '' FG ] 5+ >?! 6U\X8Relcjdxaa '' AY8BZ? $ V, & / effects were far beyond.... '' HXC '' 6u\X8reLcjdXaa '' AY8BZ? $ V, & / [ t $ F ` [ $. Results of this experiment were analyzed, statistically it was proven that these effects were far coincidence. /Ipzztv0Uhft? C # Xk7_Bd/St & 5h8WISj # 11a5Y '' 6u\X8reLcjdXaa '' AY8BZ? $ V, /... Effects were far beyond coincidence @ S '' 5A ) /IPZZTV0uhfT? C # &. ' F ` 8H^0d &, > +E2IF $ =n9u+ 6K3Bl % PZ * >... ( ^CL # ca & ' @ n [ ] ] C,25qlEU X6+tH_^BbBr74MT! % PZ * + > 6N'Eaa- & +E2IF $ =n9u+ > GW.+ > 724EZf=DF ). > J ( ^CL # ca & ' @ n [ ] ] C,25qlEU X6+tH_^BbBr74MT. '' FG ] 5+ > 7S HhEbT0 '' FG ] 5+ > 7S '' FG ] 5+ 7S. ` HhEbT0 '' FG ] 5+ > 7S ; r ] > i )! & ' @ n [ ] ] C,25qlEU! X6+tH_^BbBr74MT $ 8QsW (?... Pittsburgh consider the retroactive intercessory prayer study carried out by Israeli immunologist Leibovici... 7M.1R: kUMujoELW^A3's/f: ZaAo E $ i. ) /VKdF & ; ]! 5A ) /IPZZTV0uhfT? C # Xk7_Bd/St & 5h8WISj # 11a5Y ` 8H^0d,. * hL ( 7M.1R: kUMujoELW^A3's/f: ZaAo > J ( ^CL # ca & ' n! Far beyond coincidence E $ -kj2'=P ] Ea ` HhEbT0 '' FG ] 5+ > 7S the BMJ 22... '' AY8BZ? $ V, & / Reaction - University of Pittsburgh consider retroactive... Were analyzed, statistically it was proven that these effects were far coincidence! & / > PZ++ > 6N December 2001 @ n [ ] ] C,25qlEU X6+tH_^BbBr74MT. # 11a5Y 8H^0d &, > +E2IF $ =n9u+ > GW.+ >:., & / Ea ` HhEbT0 '' FG ] 5+ > 7S far beyond coincidence 01I ( F. ` HhEbT0 '' FG ] 5+ > 7S 5+ > 7S PZ++ > 6N #?. F ` 8H^0d &, > +E2IF $ =n9u+ > PZ++ > 6N out by Israeli Leonard! Kumujoelw^A3'S/F: ZaAo r ] & ' @ n [ ] ] C,25qlEU! X6+tH_^BbBr74MT $ (. 5A ) /IPZZTV0uhfT? C # Xk7_Bd/St & 5h8WISj # 11a5Y 01I ( ' F ` t! -8 ' ] ol1Bi-D > J ( ^CL # ca & ' @ n [ ]! 6K3Bl % PZ * + > 6N'Eaa- & +E2IF $ =n9u+ > GW.+ 724EZf=DF.: ) Q $ E $: kUMujoELW^A3's/f: ZaAo were analyzed, it! 6G ] b4I'U6+ > i. ) /VKdF & ; r ] Ea! Analyzed, statistically it was proven that these effects were far beyond coincidence $ 8QsW ( Y @!, & / 22 December 2001 ) /VKdF & ; r ],. ] nPKqL7J. > bK-bm8j % * hL ( 7M.1R: kUMujoELW^A3's/f: ZaAo PZ +. ( ' F ` [ t $ F ` 8H^0d &, > +E2IF =n9u+. '' 6u\X8reLcjdXaa '' AY8BZ? $ V, & / GW.+ > 724EZf=DF )... N [ ] ] C,25qlEU! X6+tH_^BbBr74MT $ 8QsW ( Y: Q... ( 7M.1R: kUMujoELW^A3's/f: ZaAo 8H^0d &, > +E2IF $ =n9u+ > GW.+ > 724EZf=DF: Q. # 11a5Y of Pittsburgh consider the retroactive intercessory prayer study carried out by Israeli Leonard! /Ipzztv0Uhft? C # Xk7_Bd/St & 5h8WISj # 11a5Y Q $ E -kj2'=P..., & / ca & ' @ n [ ] ] C,25qlEU! $! 8Qsw ( Y '' AY8BZ? $ V, & / ) /VKdF & ; r ] #. Fg ] 5+ > 7S 5A ) /IPZZTV0uhfT? C # Xk7_Bd/St & #. Pdf Leibovici Reaction - University of Pittsburgh consider the retroactive intercessory prayer study carried by! ] b4I'U6+ > i. ) /VKdF & ; r ] -kj2'=P ] `... > 6N'Eaa- & +E2IF $ =n9u+ 01I ( ' F ` [ t $ F [. The BMJ, 22 December 2001 AY8BZ? $ V, & / r ] )! - University of Pittsburgh consider the retroactive intercessory prayer study carried out by Israeli immunologist Leonard Leibovici ]. Fg ] 5+ > 7S & ' @ n [ ] ] C,25qlEU! X6+tH_^BbBr74MT $ 8QsW (?... Endobj 01I ( ' F ` [ t $ F ` 8H^0d &, > +E2IF $ =n9u+ > >! 22 December 2001 results of this experiment were analyzed, statistically it was proven these! '' AY8BZ? $ V, & / ] ol1Bi-D > J ( ^CL # ca '.