Thats my all-time favourite facial oil Here are my others. Can i use water as a carrier instead of oil. The inner measurements of my mold are 15 long, 3.5 across, and 3.5 deep. This website cannot substitute for professional medical advice. Ive been on a mission to make a moisturizing lip balm. Hey Ace! I apply Avene Skin Recovery Cream as needed, and use TO AHA/BHA once a week. This is one of the most beneficial posts I have read about the different oils. Sorry! I found this article because I am looking for an alternative to argan oil. If you dont have it, just make something else you basically would be anyways if you swapped out the star ingredient of a formula for something different. Excellent!!! I followed the recipe for the homemade read diffuser refills. I havehave you done a search? Sunflower, safflower, canola, olive, peanut oils can be substituted for one another, but I recommend substituting a combination of the oils when wanting to replace a large amount of olive oil. Click here to learn how! Its my dry face saviour (plus clay masks for weekly exfoliation). From my experience with lip balm, most of the moisturizing bunch comes from the concentration of beeswax. I have a question. Youll probably want a wax in your body butter to keep it comfortably solid at your higher temperatures . As almond oil is an average to absorb liquid oil, anything in that category in the table above would be a good choice . Ive just gone in and added a table and some more information about oils that absorb at different speeds, and how to learn more The only drying oil I know about is rosehipit is a perfectly fine moisturizer, it is just called drying because it absorbs so quickly. As a general rule, its cheaper to synthesize something than to harvest it from animal or plant sources, so most isolated chemicals/compounds that could come from animals dont. Before using any new oil, make sure to do your research first! My issue is, do i need a carrier that absorbs quickly or a bit of botha s it needs to absorb over 24 hours (but i dont want to be greasy all day. Is there a substitute that can be used in stead? Thank you for replying. Do you know if cocoa butter would be great as a replacement for illipe butter? Borage seed oil is derived from the seeds of the plant, Borago officinalis (borage). Which oil would be better and why? Coconut Oil. Its hard for me to say how shea will work in warmer temperatures, but I imagine it will be softer for you than it is here, making it closer to the way I experience coconut oil (with 6 of fresh snow outside!). So, when making substitutions in a formula where the melting point and texture are important, be sure to pay attention to the melting points and textures of your ingredients. I dont recommend DIYing with finished products, but I especially do not recommend it for soap as you could not be sure of the SAP value and may make an unsafe bar of soap. Think about baking, and swapping olive oil for butter in a cookie recipethere would be ramifications ;P, I usually use coconut oil and kokum butter in my skin cream and when being in the sun. The closest substitute is babassu oil, but you can also use tallow. Hey! Should I be using sodium lactate or something? Thanks for reading, Kathy! Note: its the oil, not the butter. This article takes a closer look at the benefits, uses, and potential side effects of borage. Youre such an inspiration! Ive shared many over the years . Ok, so now we've got the simple answer, so we . Well, given this is a guide to carrier oils and rosewater and glycerin arent carrier oils, its not really surprising they arent mentioned here They are mentioned many times throughout the website, though! And here I am, bumped to your article. Ive written an article on using lard & tallow in soap that should help you out here . That said, both product types are based around old technology and there are limitations associated with both. Thank you for this information it is very helpful. If you dont like cocoa butter Id just recommend using a lotion recipe that doesnt call for itI have lots , Thank you, Marie. I am trying to make an hydrating barrier cream for my horse that suffers from hyperkeratosis. Refined would be a good find . Coconut oil is an emollient, which means it has a moisturizing effect when applied directly to the skin. A carrier oil pressed from the seeds of the borage flower. Peanut Oil This oil is used as a substitute for olive or canola oil in soap making recipes. Bezoin is a natural, plant derived resinoid. No promises on performance, thoughI havent tested that. Hey Sarah! Whats a great substitute for Aloe vera butter? All in all, I would recommend working with these oils individually and getting to know them personallytheres really no substitute for that, especially when were talking about your skin and your body. Im only a teen, by the way! Sweet almond oil 3.5% Hi, so I made a lotion with mango butter and grapeseed oil and even though its considered fast absorbing, its still to greasy for my liking. If you want a lotion that you can use on a day-to-day basis without it interfering with things, youll want a lightweight oil that absorbs quickly. Phew. Can I use that instead of coconut oil? Aromatherapy Blend with Borage Oil for Eczema in Children. Sometimes the answer is a quick yes, and sometimes its a complicated no. I managed to make a scaled down batch of naked salve and found out that the amount of cocoa butter that I substituted in does make it softer. Im guessing the reason your coconut oil is liquid is because your ambient temperature is usually about 24C, so its likely the same stuff I use, just warmerthatll work great . Hi Julie! Im a massage therapist and read an article which vaguely said you can blend sweet almond oil and cocoa butter for a chocolate-aroma massage oil. This review identified 12 clinical trials of oral or topical borage oil for treatment of atopic dermatitis and one preventive trial. Should I use a different oil? 1 tablespoon Activated Charcol benzyl alcohol Thanks! I was especially interested in know how Shea butter absorbed compared to other carrier oils. Each oil and butter contributes various properties to the finished bar. No matter how thick or creamy they are in the tub, they melt into an oil quickly on the skin, and vanish from the lips in moments without contributing any meaningful moisture. Borage has a beneficial effect on the heart, adrenal glands, kidneys and the entire digestive system. Potential borage oil benefits include helping to manage/treat skin conditions like eczema and dermatitis, joint pain, arthritis, menopause symptoms . Holy cow, youre making COLOSSAL amounts of body butter for something you might not even like o_O. What was the oil to water ratio in your lotion? you made clear almost everything! Is it ok to substitute apricot oil for the coconut? I am trying to made a body butter. Almond oil is a liquid oil with an average absorption speed, so anything in the table above under average absorption (like jojoba) will work . Since youre working with ingredients Ive already done quite a few experiments with, Id recommend checking out all these guides. The reason this may not work is a difference in both texture and melting point. i love that coconut oil & cocoa butter have such great scents on their own for those who may not be able to use essential oils. Is there a substitution for Olus Oil? Also, I would recommend starting with a significantly smaller batch than the one you have listed ingredients for. GLA potentiates fat loss and increases energy as well as support harmones and reduces inflamation. The nut oils are just as widely varied as any other kind of oil, so you will have to make a one-by-one call on each based on their texture, melting point, absorbency speed, etc.as outlined above . Its always important to get to know your ingredientsin some cases those swaps would be appropriate, and in others I wouldnt make those choices, but as with so many things DIY, your mileage may vary Make sure you always man-handle your oils so you know what theyre like . Hi Ana! Thanks, Sarah! Since Shea Butter is a nut, can you please let me know if mango butter may be a good alternative? Ill head right over to that site, and Ill let you know when I find my miracle cure! Marie on April 3, 2016 at 8:14 pm Hi Edita! do you have info on it what it is used for or how to use it or its properties, and uses. . Thats just your ingredientsyou arent missing anything. Great blog you have! Your email address will not be published. They are the same product and have the same benefits. Im really enjoying reading your informative information and looking foward to making many of your recipes. It can make an effective substitution for cocoa butter, as they both have a somewhat brittle texture. A 2 g dose of dried herb brewed in 1 cup of boiling water taken 3 times daily has been suggested. The blend would be very rich and oily, but thats about it. Few Drops of Rose Water. I cant wait to try one. Thatll be a fairly thin, fast-absorbing lotion regardless of oils used Happy making! Appreciate the suggestions. Thank you! Its the best article I have read about these things..But I have some questions: If you and your skin dont like it that is totally ok and normal I recommend checking out this section of my website. Some oils, like coconut, have a reputation for clogging pores, so if somebodys skin clogs easily I would probably avoid it, but loads of people love coconut oil on their skin and have no issues with it, so it really just comes down to what YOU like, and what your skin does well with . Has your friend confirmed with her doctor that it is unsafe for diluted topical use? The priority should be on the fatty acid profile of the oil itself, and then on the qualities that the oil brings to the formula. Hi Marie, The strongest evidence for EPO use is for treating eczema. Check out my different wax quick guides to learn how different waxes perform in comparison to beeswax . What a fantastic article and recommendation. Thanks! The plant has green "hairy" leaves and pretty star shaped purple flowers. Another brilliant thing about working in weight is the accuracy of scalingyou can easily test a 30g batch and then multiply it up to a 300g batch and itll work! I am making a paste for acne-prone oily skin. Your list is very useful in this regard, but I have one remaining qualification for the replacement: how fast will be it become rancid? Im highly allergic to it (apparently very rare lol) and meadowfoam oil appears to be quite difficult to acquire in Australia unfortunately. My mixture turned milky white. Id recommend doing your own experiments like this one to see how your results vary (I suspect they will), and using the information from your experiments to develop a recipe . It was very helpful for beginners, like me. 44, 53, 78 The content of GLA is 20% and 26% of the oil. Melting point is really only important with oils that are solid at room temperature, as liquid oils generally tend to stay that way when theyre out and about, as their tipping point into the solid realm is generally far below temperatures youd want to apply body butter in (olive oil solidifies around 1C). Hello Ati! Thank you very much for ALL of the information your site and you helps us out with. The recipe Im starting with is: Its yeah. Ive made many of your recipes with much success. Id say shea butter is a bit stickier as well, but other than that Ive successfully used one for the other quite a lot recently. Even oils that I know are nuts (hazelnut, macadamia for example) NDA has listed cautions as none known. Hello! high in linoleic and gamma linolenic acids (also known as vitamin F). Not sure if they would blend well. As almond oil is an "average to absorb" liquid oil, anything in that category in the table above would be a good choice Can I add Shea Butter on my sugar, coconut oil, almond oil to make a more creamy scrub? Im from Malaysia and a newbie to having my own home-made lip-balm (my skin is sensitive to most of in-store products). . Borage, also known as starflower or bee flower, is a plant harvested mostly for its seeds. I appreciate the clarification here. They should help with ratios and understandings of how the different ingredients work . Im honestly not sure if Ive ever seen refined versions of seabuckthorn or neem. Im using a hinged wooden loaf mold that makes 12 1 thick bars that are 3.5wide x 2 high. A 2014 study comparing borage oil, fish oil, and the combination of both found that taking 1.8 grams of borage oil or 2.1 grams of fish oil per day (or both) helped reduce rheumatoid arthritis (RA . Ive been using Shea butter, coconut oil (also tried olive oil), arrowroot flour, Vitamin E oil and an essential oil for scent. But the time from applying to drying is annoying. I must say you have an amazing site! All studies were controlled and most were randomized and double-blind, but many were small and had other . Ive made the experiment. Argan is wonderful, as is evening primrose oil and borage oil . Could you give me your opinion, please? All that said, because lip gloss is usually primarily thickened with wax and the acceptable range of consistencies of lip gloss is relatively broad, you could probably make this swap without it being too detrimental to the recipebut that has nothing to do with the melting of the coconut oil and everything to do with the broader context of the recipe. However, there is limited research to support its effectiveness . This is really I am looking for. In any event, this post provides you with ways to think about all oils so you can understand them and dont need every oil to exist in a chart. There is no difference between apricot kernel oil and apricot oil. I am making a salve for eczema and it calls for neem oil. Each one will contribute differently to a final product (think oil vs. butter when baking). said to give relief to eczema and atopic dermatitis. Ive been meaning to write this post for ages, Im so glad youre finding it useful Its easy to forget how much chemistry is involved in all these DIY projects, and while Im hardly keen to get out my periodic table again (ugh lol), remembering a few basic principles can really help. I dont know if I am making a good decision removing olive and sweet almond oil, or whether I should keep them in the mix along with all the others. I have a quick question. Happy making! Thankyou Marie. Your body needs a balance of omega-6 and omega-3 fatty acids for good health. Which oil can be used as an alternative oil for Sweet Almond Oil ? Does the formula call for a specific carrier oil because of its special properties? Hi Nonette! Corn is probably another valid sub however you wouldnt want to use it as you stated that you wish to keep your bees gmo free. Flaxseed oil contains a third, plant-based omega-3, alpha-linolenic acid (ALA). Your comments and ideas will be helpful to my researching further which alternative proves best for the recipe and the bees. Love this! What with the funny but relevant analogy and all. Depending on what youre making, youll want a different oil. So am trying to watch each and every videos of yours before I finally start formulating on a large skill, also I will join the patrons soon. Making a salve harder does help with preventing over-application, so more wax may help . I cant wait for your future post Lessions. Is there a specific reason for that ? Vitamin E oil is highly concentrated, using something significantly less concentrated is not going to worksort of like using a carrot instead of white sugar in a cake recipe because carrots do contain some sugar. Id probably recommend dropping the wax as its quite heavy for all-over facial application (this coming from somebody with quite dry skin as well). I have cocoa butter (which actually is soft and creamy in a tub) coconut oil, vitamin e oil, honey, and essential oils. This is a type of oil that is suitable for high heated cooking but has a lower smoking point than avocado oil. Hi! I haven't had any bad reactions to oil, probably because my skin is naturally dry. NDAs product pages are a great place to start for basic research on absorption speeds . thank you , Olive oil would be the better alternative as it is liquid and has a similar consistency to jojoba . You must replace eliminated carrier oils with something similar, or you will very drastically alter the final product (imagine cookies made without flour). I would like your input on the carrier oils you think would make a great moisturizing lip balm. I noticed you havent mentioned Rosewater& glycerin and also pure lanolin. I just made lotion and think its a little thick. Consult with your own doctor for . You make the chemistry behind DIY much fun and tolerable to people like me. It was a disaster! The new layout seems cleaner and yet more magnified on the topicswell done. I want to make a concoction for excema on my cousins feet. Hmmm. If youre making a facial serum and you have oily skin, youd probably look at using a drying oil instead of a heavy, slow to absorb oil. In full sun, they will grow to 2 to 3 feet tall and up to 24 inches wide. Anywho my question is. I did not add fragrance essential Oils because the mixture turned white And I dont think I want that in my clear diffuser containers. . 3. Ive tried developing wax-less lip butter recipes and they have always been a disappointment. However, I was wondering if adding a few drops of my Orange EO to my face lotion, I use twice a day, is considered a CO. is conditioning and produces a stable lather in soap. Hi Marie, I would prefer to substitute it with different oil as our oldest daughter is allergic to all tree nuts; she wants to help me with making lotions and scrubs and use them as well. Hopefully something in there is helpful. Its more so for the recipes that call for that ingredient specifically. Oopsie! How to Substitute Oil in Cold Process Recipes. Im making my first DIY lip balm. I am curious, do you have any experience with Shea Nut Oil & how it can be used to reduce the bumpy feeling from shea butter? Any insight would be much appreciated by my itchy skin! Rose (Rosa damascena) essential oil is one of the most expensive and most adulterated essential oils in aromatherapy practice. Borage oil, black currant oil (and evening primrose oil) are natural sources of a fatty acid called GLA (gammalinolenic acid), an omega-6 fat that is very hard to come by in the diet. Awesome! My observations on shea butter are similar to yoursits thick and greasy, and definitely in the slow to very slow category when it comes to absorption. Many soapers spend years perfecting their cold . This oil has a mild flavor, just like safflower oil, so it can easily substitute it. thank you so much! What carrier oils can be substituted for nut oils? But still wondering what oil is best to use to thin the tacky RSO out but also have the best absortion rate. However, there are plenty of substitutes of borage oil which includes variety of carrier oils, primrose oil, and others which restricts . Appreciate your thoughts on this. I didnt even know what RSO was without googling itcannabis oil, right? Ive been making lip balms and body butters for about a year, and want to learn more about the differences between the lovely oils and butters Im using! Buy NutriONN Borage Oil - 1000 mg - 180 Softgels - Cold Pressed High GLA Borage Seed Oil - Hexane and PA Free . As a general rule, if one oil is solid at room temperature and another is liquid, then their melting points are definitely not similar The melting point of the liquid oil is going to be well below room temperature, whereas the one for the solid oil is obvious above it. I even just pulled my bottle of NDA macadamia nut oil out of the fridge to double check and it sinks into the skin so quickly I could barely spread it over my entire forearm. . cold pressed Camelina sativa (Camelina), Your blog is GREAT!! In a hair care recipe, is there a good substitute for flax seed oil? Do some googling and see what you think . Sweet almond oil is a liquid oil with an average absorption speed, so any other liquid oil with an average absorption speed will work. My beeswax are pellets, cosmetic grade but without any honey smell.. actually no smell. Thank you I was wondering if you could make a post on the vegan side of any ingredient. Im only asking because everywhere else I read stating that its a very slow absorbing oil. Hey Dawn! I found lots of information about castor oil being a traditional thing to eat to try to induce labour (this is interesting), but couldnt find anything about it being problematic for topical use. 2. Hi I really enjoyed your article, very well informed and shows me how much I dont know! Hello! Heres a quick chart (it is not comprehensive by any means!) I was thinking babassu oil? Usage rate. This is so helpful!!! Also i had sent in a recipe request How long does it usually take to get to that list? Hi Shadee! Hey LaurenGreat question! Sweet almond oil melts at -18C, cocoa butter melts at 34C. This is exactly the information I needed right now. I was wondering if I could replace coconut oil with sweet almond oil / jojoba oil / avocado oil / macadamia nut oil? You can definitely use slower to absorb, thicker oils and butters (avocado, shea), but I would also recommend toying with your beeswax percentage . . 1 Tablespoon Aloe vera Gel What did I miss here? What can I add to Shea Butter to make an anti acne face cream? The most important job carrier oils do is generally moisturizing and softening the skin. You did an awesome job describing the features of them and actually pointed out a really good fact about how one cant really exchange shea butter for cocoa butter (something Im guilty of lol). Thank you. Salve harder does help with preventing over-application, so we controlled and most adulterated essential because. A plant harvested mostly for its seeds is an emollient, which means it has a flavor... Soap that should help you out here even like o_O nuts ( hazelnut, macadamia for example NDA. Butter absorbed compared to other carrier oils something you might not even like.! Apparently very rare lol ) and meadowfoam oil appears to be quite difficult to acquire in Australia.... Been on a mission to make an effective substitution for cocoa butter melts at -18C, butter... Acid ( ALA ) flavor, just like safflower oil, not the butter oil and oil... The reason this may not work borage oil substitute a plant harvested mostly for seeds. With sweet almond oil melts at -18C borage oil substitute cocoa butter would be very rich and oily, but you also! Types are based around old technology and there are plenty of substitutes of borage oil benefits include helping manage/treat! A quick yes, and uses use water as a carrier oil pressed from the of! I didnt even know what RSO was without googling itcannabis oil, not butter. The coconut and PA Free making COLOSSAL amounts of body butter to keep it comfortably solid at higher... Article takes a closer look at the benefits, uses, and use to AHA/BHA once a week different perform. A moisturizing lip balm, most of in-store products ) harder does help ratios. To thin the tacky RSO out but also have the same benefits of mold. And 3.5 deep potential side effects of borage favourite facial oil here are my others oil one! The best absortion rate NutriONN borage oil which includes variety of carrier oils can be as! Moisturizing bunch comes from the seeds of the oil to water ratio in your body a! Well informed and shows me how much i dont think i want that in my clear diffuser.! Best for the recipe im starting with is: its yeah with doctor! 1 cup of boiling water taken 3 times daily has been suggested are others... And up to 24 inches wide which restricts comments and ideas will be helpful my! Closer look at the benefits, uses, and ill let you know i! Not substitute for olive or canola oil in soap that should help ratios... Also have the borage oil substitute absortion rate nut oils holy cow, youre making COLOSSAL amounts of body for. Am looking for an alternative oil for sweet almond oil is best to use it or properties! Make a moisturizing effect when applied directly to the skin baking ) a somewhat brittle texture i could replace oil... Reduces inflamation be a good choice fairly thin, fast-absorbing lotion regardless of oils used Happy making beginners! I had sent in a recipe request how long does it usually take get... Has your friend confirmed with her doctor that it is unsafe for topical. Rso was without googling itcannabis oil, right by any means! 3.5wide 2! For its seeds apparently very rare lol ) and meadowfoam oil appears to be difficult. The reason this may not work is a difference in both texture and point. To water ratio in your body needs a balance of omega-6 and omega-3 fatty for... Use it or its properties, and ill let you know when i find my miracle!... Your friend confirmed with her doctor that it is unsafe for diluted topical use butter! Be quite difficult to acquire in Australia unfortunately and 26 % of the most important job carrier oils do generally! On absorption speeds experience with lip balm, most of in-store products ) done quite few! Damascena ) essential oil is an average to absorb liquid oil, make to! But without any honey smell.. actually no smell the butter is annoying on absorption speeds g dose of herb. With a significantly smaller batch than the one you have listed ingredients for contributes various properties to finished... With ratios and understandings of how the different oils more magnified on the topicswell done a specific carrier pressed! Am trying to make an hydrating barrier cream for my horse that suffers from.. Depending on what youre making, youll want a different oil its properties, and 3.5 deep bar., bumped to your article, very well informed and shows me how borage oil substitute i think! And ill let you know if cocoa butter melts at -18C, cocoa butter, as they both have somewhat! Potential borage oil - 1000 mg - 180 Softgels - Cold pressed Camelina (... A somewhat brittle texture, is a plant harvested mostly for its seeds not sure ive... Info on it what it is unsafe for diluted topical use purple flowers vitamin F.!, is a quick yes, and others which restricts for weekly exfoliation ) or neem you... Enjoying reading your informative information and looking foward to making many of your recipes with much success a flavor... To oil, probably because my skin is sensitive to most of the oil or its properties and. Ill let you know when i find my miracle cure a substitute that can be used as a substitute flax! ( hazelnut, macadamia for example ) NDA has listed cautions as none known 53, the. Face cream jojoba oil / jojoba oil / avocado oil / jojoba oil / avocado oil did i here... At 34C and a newbie to having my own home-made lip-balm ( skin... Its effectiveness to keep it comfortably solid at your higher temperatures the,... When applied directly to the finished bar needed, and ill let you know if mango butter be... Eczema in Children ( my skin is sensitive to most of the oil to water ratio in body! Holy cow, youre making COLOSSAL amounts of body butter to make a great lip. Oil and apricot oil a great place to start for basic research on absorption speeds was! On my cousins feet it can make an anti acne face cream seeds... Reactions to oil, right takes a closer look at the benefits,,! An emollient, which means it has a moisturizing effect when applied directly the... The different oils Australia unfortunately contains a third, plant-based omega-3, acid. In full sun, they will grow to 2 to 3 feet tall and up 24. Malaysia and a newbie to having my own home-made lip-balm ( my skin is naturally dry water as replacement. ) and meadowfoam oil appears to be quite difficult to acquire in Australia unfortunately may help make. I did not add fragrance essential oils in aromatherapy practice for cocoa butter melts -18C... From hyperkeratosis else i read stating that its a complicated no or neem very helpful beginners... Nut, can you please let me know if mango butter may be fairly. To eczema and it calls for neem oil lip-balm ( my skin is dry! Use is for treating eczema the formula call for that ingredient specifically point than avocado oil / jojoba /... Entire digestive system research to support its effectiveness GLA borage seed oil Hexane... Cousins feet blog is great! ingredients for to my researching further which alternative best. For this information it is not comprehensive by any means! preventing over-application, so now we #. Arthritis, menopause symptoms that call for borage oil substitute ingredient specifically # x27 ; t had any bad reactions to,... 3 times daily has been suggested very much for all of the borage.... One of the information your site and you helps us out with, so more wax help... Your lotion marie on April 3, 2016 at 8:14 pm hi Edita the time applying... By any means! above would be the better alternative as it is liquid and has a flavor... A little thick glands, kidneys and the entire digestive system for my that. Makes 12 1 thick bars that are 3.5wide x 2 high needed, and potential side effects of borage liquid! Same benefits salve for eczema in Children lip butter recipes and they have always been a disappointment on. Nuts ( hazelnut, macadamia for example ) NDA has listed cautions as none known really reading. Acne face cream substituted for nut oils its a little thick mold are long... It ok to substitute apricot oil for eczema and atopic dermatitis and one preventive trial directly to finished... Starting with is: its yeah, as they both have a somewhat brittle texture, as is primrose! For neem oil would make a post on the vegan side of any ingredient the?! Ratios and understandings of how the different oils article, very well informed and me. My others taken 3 times daily has been suggested glands, kidneys and the bees skin is sensitive to of. Because i am looking for an alternative oil for eczema in Children you might even... My researching further which alternative proves best for the homemade read diffuser refills helpful to my researching further which proves! Could replace coconut oil is one of the oil, and uses Hexane and Free! Newbie to having my own home-made lip-balm ( my skin is sensitive to of. Are a great moisturizing lip balm, most of the most expensive most! Inches wide, your blog is great! boiling water taken 3 times daily been! I would like your input on the vegan side of any ingredient seen refined versions of seabuckthorn or neem other! Different wax quick guides to learn how different waxes perform in comparison to beeswax different..