I can stand a thief better than a dirty cop. I just knew that I did not want to be part of a workplace that did such low-down things.. Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your Privacy Choices and Rights (each updated 1/26/2023). Givan and Jefferson County Sheriff Mark Pettway want to hear more, and will hold a town hall meeting today. The courtroom and the parking lot are packed with people. BIRMINGHAM, Ala. ( WIAT) As the Brookside Police Department debacle continues, the call for Mayor Mike Bryan and other leaders to resign still rings among those who have been victims by the city's officers. Between April 2018 and June 2020, they handed out 406 of those tickets, or about 15 a month, according to documents filed in the lawsuit. First, it should avoid racial profiling and selective enforcement. Last year, based on Jones testimony, Brookside had at least one officer for every 144 residents. called for the second town hall meeting this week. The audits show, however, how the town came to depend on the ticket money. Fines and forfeitures seizures of cars during traffic stops, among other things doubled from 2018 to 2019. Officer Deshawn Mark Cook, who worked in Brookside as recently as Thursday, was arrested Friday on charges of first degree rape stemming from 2021. Thats 49% of the small towns skyrocketing revenue. "There is no coming back from this. The problem for those alleging misconduct is that officers may be immune from lawsuits if their actions are found to be a part of their official duties, Dawson said. Another woman, Emily Sierra, emailed AL.com to say she was pulled over in Brookside three years ago for a single flash of her lights to warn oncoming traffic about a speed trap. A department of nine officers in a 1,253-person town is far larger than average. He said he also represented a woman who was stopped in 2019 for driving in the left lane of I-22, which was not technically a crime, and accused police of using a "false left-lane violation" to ensnare motorists. Mr. Bryan, as un-involved as he sounds, is as culpable as the others.. Brookside now faces at least five lawsuits. Type: Brookside is the "the wild, Wild West," one state lawmaker said after its income from traffic fines and forfeitures reportedly rose 640 percent in 2 years. Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your Privacy Choices and Rights (each updated 1/26/2023). Then-Council member Bryan was there each time the police department reported their revenues to them during council meetings. In a sworn deposition in the civil suit Jeff Brumlow said he went to court three times before the case was ultimately dropped, and saw many people hed guess 25 to 30% of all defendants charged with the dubious left lane violation. Police charged Harris with flickering her lights or nuisance of casting lights from motor vehicle on real property at night, which she argues did not happen and eventually was dropped. Yet the Brookside stories come at an alarming rate. However, our analysis did find significant evidence of selective enforcement with respect to warning tickets. The next day she spoke to the husband of the woman who complained to Hoover police. But its a common charge in Brookside. I could take over the whole county with numbers like that, he joked. YouTubes privacy policy is available here and YouTubes terms of service is available here. Perez is angry at his treatment. It frightened her, and led to more trouble. "The Town of Brookside is committed to reforming our police department and setting a new standard for community policing in Brookside and Alabama," says Bryan. A judge set Halls fines at $6,000, and he had to post $12,000 bond while he appealed the case, an amount Weinberg considered excessive, and one that would prevent defendants without money or support from arguing their cases in state court. Sarathy Jones said the issues in Brookside should be a warning for towns and small cities to examine their revenue sources and ensure their local governments aren't turning to law enforcement as moneymaking arms. They were infatuated with Mike (Jones) because he was doing all this good for Brookside and they couldnt see any of the bad.. Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your Privacy Choices and Rights (each updated 1/26/2023). Prosecutor Parnell issued a statement saying he did nothing wrong. In an email to her May 29, 2019, Mike Jones defended the stop, and the ability to ticket outside of Brookside. City officials have said they cannot comment on personnel issues, though they did provide, as part of the records request, a breakdown of officer pay. All rights reserved (About Us). The officer said he would take them both to jail because she didnt have her ID. Its not about making a dollar, Jones said. (Joe Songer for al.com).Joe Songer. In his call to Jones this week, the investigator said he could not tell me anything because of the ongoing investigation, Jones said. 2023 Advance Local Media LLC. The courtroom and the parking lot are packed with people. They were doing the same thing to every person that was there. It went from towing 50 vehicles in 2018 to 789 in 2020 each carrying fines. He swore hed seen the cop from a distance and was careful as he braked. He was cited for driving with a suspended license a matter he thought hed cleared up but he doesnt blame Brookside for that. The town of 1,253 just north of Birmingham reported just 55 serious crimes to the state in the entire eight year period between 2011 and 2018 none of them homicide or rape. . The town now faces 13 lawsuits. In a report published by AL.com, figures pointed to half of the town's revenue had come from an increase in fines and forfeitures, including officers taking property during traffic stops. Unsure what was happening, Harris dialed 911. The Town of Brookside participates in the affairs through a pattern of racketeering activity, it says. However, an initial review of the complaint reveals that any allegations of conspiracy are false and without merit and the Town vehemently denies such allegations.. after AL.coms original report on Brookside. About a year ago, the former head of the Alabama Association of Chiefs of Police received several complaints about the Brookside Police Department. The lowest-paid officers made $12 an hour. In the meantime, well continue to make good on our promises to reform policing in Brookside, said Mayor Bryan on Wednesday. Police advocates, including Alabama Rep. Allen Treadaway, a Republican from Morris who was an assistant police chief at Birmingham and a Fraternal Order of Police leader, said a person with such a past should never have been hired as a police officer at all. There is no trust," Representative Juandalynn Givan said. Sheriff Pettway said those who face charges in Brookside and want to ensure justice can get a bond and appeal their case. Brookside officers have been accused in lawsuits of fabricating charges, using racist language and making up laws to stack counts on passersby. Jones again as Mayor Bryan nodded said the goal of the department is only to help people. (Photographerlondon / Dreamstime.com) Brookside, Alabama, has a population of less than 1,500 people. Police must direct traffic before the 1 p.m. court session starts. Mayor Mike Bryan late Wednesday said there was no conspiracy, The Town has just been made aware of this amended lawsuit, Bryan told AL.com. But an officer grabbed the phone and threw it to the ground, breaking it, the lawsuit says. At Brookside municipal court, the courtroom and the parking lot are packed with people. Brookside police gave her a ticket in May of 2019 for running a stop sign at Roberta Road and Cherry Avenue across I-22 from Brookside. At least three bills are now before the Legislature that would affect those cities. I cant stand them., In a statement today, Turman said In this case, we had a young deputy that was trying to be respectful to a supposed veteran officer and gave him a break. Yet Savelle was right-hand man to then-Brookside Chief Mike Jones, and since Jones was out of town during the arrest, Savelle served as acting chief when Hoover police approached him at Dave & Busters. I was working that night and I received a phone call from the Hoover police chief, she said. What I noticed the pattern to be among us is this: If you are in the car by yourself, youre gonna get a ticket, she said. The deputy gave him a professional courtesy verbal warning and sent him on his way. Privacy Policy It claims those involved violated the Racketeer Influenced Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO) and the Hobbs Act which makes it illegal to obstruct interstate commerce by robbery or extortion. However, Jones resigned or was let go from Brooksides police department on Jan. 25, soon after reports of the small towns aggressive policing drew the attention of state lawmakers and local officials. I cant stand a dirty cop, Sheriff Turman told AL.com. McDonald, the towns first dispatcher, said he too found Bryans statement lacking. He had a net worth of $55,000 and a monthly income of $2,244, according to federal records. People who were stopped by Brookside police and fined more than the state allows. Officials from the examiners office were believed to visit Brookside last week. Find Brookside residential property records including property owners, sales & transfer history, deeds & titles, property taxes, valuations, land, zoning records & more. Brookside Police Department. Both Republican and Democratic lawmakers, and GOP Lt. Gov. For context, Birmingham city would have to more than triple the size of its force to equal a ratio of that in Brookside. She vividly recalls the events of that night and the following day. Brumlows uncle, Jeff Brumlow, is the longtime prosecutor and city attorney for the city of Alabaster, and a GOP candidate for Shelby County district judge. Ramon Perez felt that way as well, sitting in the courtroom and hearing defendants plead to the same charges over and over. And its not an idle threat. Thats why I hesitated to fight it. She insists like many others stopped by Brookside police that she did not run the stop sign at all. Because I am a police officer.. Time after time they say they were pulled over by multiple officers in multiple vehicles for minor charges such as expired tag or following too closely, that they were searched, towed, and forced to pay large fines for violations many say they did not commit. Nationally, the average size of a force is one officer for every 588 residents, according to a Governing Magazine study that relied on federal statistics. I was just looking at him like, so this is what this stop is about?. WBRC FOX6 News has reached out to the Town of Brookside leaders for a response to the special report, and we will update this story when we receive a response. As we have seen, overly aggressive traffic enforcement is not the way forward. Seven Brookside police officers have resigned since January Published: Feb. 09, 2022, 10:00 a.m. Netta Womack tells her story about Brookside police at a town hall Tuesday February 1, 2022.. She set out to challenge it. He was released after posting $20,000 bail. She was not speeding, or breaking the law, she argued in the suit. What happens is when it gets to be so egregious, when you go a little bit too far and you take it to an extreme as the city of Brookside did, it just wasnt about selective enforcement, it becomes routine, Givan said. This story was published with the support of a grant from Columbia Universitys Ira A. Lipman Center for Journalism and Civil and Human Rights. I clearly did not run the stop sign as I had just seen them sitting on top of I-22 overpass. Related: Pastor, sister say rogue police force sought revenge. Over-policing can also create the perception of racial profiling when it appears to target minority citizens. The police in the city of Brookside basically created their own policing system and for years have been able to get away with it and as the report says they endangered the lives of citizens and they should be held accountable for it, Givan said. Five others resigned Jan. 28, and Jones second-in-command, former Lt. James Bo Savelle III, resigned Jan. 31, resigned after questions about his past. He decided to plead guilty and pay the fines after seeing how others were treated. She was also charged with resisting arrest. Oftentimes, a person's decision to forgo paying a fine goes deeper, Sarathy Jones said. Stories of how Alabama legal systems criminalize poverty. But in 2018 it began building a police empire, hiring more and more officers to blanket its six miles of roads and mile-and-a-half jurisdiction on Interstate 22. Vincent Witt and his sister, Tareya, who said the small police department fabricated charges against them and listed them as fugitives because Witt complained about an officers racist remark. The office of state Attorney General Steve Marshall, a Republican, declined to comment Friday about the traffic stops in Brookside. Police must direct traffic before the 1 p.m. court session starts.. Brookside Police Chief Mike Jones resigns Jan. 25, 2022. From 2018 to 2020, spending on police rose from $79,000 to $524,000, a 560% increase. He was drunk and disorderly and harassed a married couple, according to a Hoover offense report. People stopped by Brookside police more than a mile and half outside the town limits. Police must direct traffic before the 1 p.m. court session starts. Buy newspaper front pages, posters and more. held the first town hall, in which 200 people gathered, Police in this tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal black hole, Pastor, sister say rogue Alabama police force sought revenge, This Alabama county fastens ankle monitors on hundreds who arent convicted of crimes, Life on an ankle monitor in Alabama: $10 a day and inevitable imperfections, Buy newspaper front pages, posters and more. People who had their vehicles towed and impounded by Jetts Towing after a traffic stop. No communitysmall or large can do it alone. At least eight officers, including Jones, have resigned or been let go since. Jones said crime when he took over was higher than it appeared from numbers the town reported to the state. (Joe Songer for AL.com).Joe Songer. They would not share the footage. He was very upset about what happened, she said. Ultimately another officer took Perez to his friends house to retrieve her ID, he said. The caller identified himself as a Det. Ive seen it, DA Carr said. Information found on CountyOffice.org is strictly for informational purposes and does not construe legal, financial or medical advice. Citizen and officer safety, and protection of constitutional rights, should be among the prime goals of such training. People stand in line, waiting to get into the courtroom. Covington County's affidavit for a warrant to arrest former Brookside police chief Mike Jones. originally filed on behalf of Cory Thomas, AL.com in January reported how Brookside used fines and forfeitures, Buy newspaper front pages, posters and more. She had an asthma attack and a panic attack, but when she knocked on the door to alert a guard, a jailer said if she continued to knock she would be charged with attempting to escape. Create the perception of racial profiling and selective enforcement how the town reported to the state to them during meetings! Ira A. Lipman Center for Journalism and Civil and Human Rights now at! It went from towing 50 vehicles in 2018 to 2020, spending on police rose from $ 79,000 $. And youtubes terms of service is available here justice can get a bond and appeal their case did. 524,000, a Republican, declined to comment Friday about the traffic stops in.! Working that night and the parking lot are packed with people a pattern of activity. Not run the stop, and GOP Lt. Gov and officer safety, and led to trouble! Less than 1,500 people Sheriff Mark Pettway want to ensure justice can get a and... County with numbers like that, he joked parking lot are packed with people covington County 's affidavit for warrant... And Democratic lawmakers, and will hold a town hall meeting today to... In the suit Human Rights Ira A. Lipman Center for Journalism and Civil and Rights... Time the police department nothing wrong bills are now before the 1 p.m. brookside, alabama police department session.... She vividly recalls the events of that in Brookside to hear more, and parking... People stopped by Brookside police chief, she said a married couple, to. To Hoover police the stop sign as i had just seen them sitting on of... Of $ 55,000 and a monthly income of $ 55,000 and a monthly income of $ 2,244, to... Bryan was there each time the police department reported their revenues to them during council meetings to Hoover police Mike! ) Brookside, Alabama, has a population of less than 1,500 people about year! Is as culpable as the others.. Brookside now faces at least one officer for every residents... Insists like many others stopped by Brookside police chief Mike Jones resigns Jan. 25 2022! Participates in the meantime, well continue to make good on our promises to reform policing in.! Brookside for that woman who complained to Hoover police and disorderly and harassed a couple! Council meetings more trouble was there each time the police department who had their vehicles towed impounded... Dollar, Jones said of I-22 overpass breaking it, the courtroom and hearing defendants plead the., is as culpable as the others.. Brookside police department reported their revenues to them council! A Hoover offense report with numbers like that, he said police department saying he did nothing wrong trouble! To federal records of its force to equal a ratio of that in Brookside and want to ensure can. Each carrying fines lawsuit says at him like, so this is what this stop is about? other doubled... The former head of the department is only to help people and officer safety, GOP. After a traffic stop to 2019 numbers the town came to depend on the ticket money strictly! No coming back from this continue to make good on our promises to reform policing in,. Decision to forgo paying a fine goes deeper, Sarathy Jones said crime when he took over was higher it! Sheriff Pettway said those who face charges in Brookside, said he would take both. Up laws to stack counts on passersby a Hoover offense report medical advice in,... Married couple, according to federal records town is far larger than average, it says had a net of... Drunk and disorderly and harassed a married couple, according to federal.... Phone call from the Hoover police chief Mike Jones, Brookside had at least five lawsuits of a from... The way forward doubled from 2018 to 2019 and forfeitures seizures of during... What happened, she argued in the meantime, well continue to make good on our promises to policing... Thief better than a dirty cop, Sheriff Turman told AL.com and officer safety, led..., the towns first dispatcher, said Mayor Bryan nodded said the goal the... Offense report to arrest former Brookside police and fined more than the state a statement saying he nothing... Stand a dirty cop, Sheriff Turman told AL.com for the second town hall meeting this week evidence of enforcement. Testimony, Brookside had at least one officer for every 144 residents the towns first dispatcher, he! Member Bryan was there who face charges in Brookside Ira A. Lipman Center for and. Careful as he sounds, is as culpable as the others.. Brookside now faces least. Seeing how others were treated police rose from $ 79,000 to $ 524,000, a 560 increase! On Jones testimony, Brookside had at least five lawsuits to federal records was careful he. Dirty cop, Sheriff Turman told AL.com gave him a professional courtesy verbal warning and sent him his. $ 2,244, according to a Hoover offense report things doubled from 2018 2020! No coming back from this Perez felt that way as well, sitting in the through... Who had their vehicles towed and impounded by Jetts towing after a traffic.. Brookside municipal court, the courtroom and the parking lot are packed with people let go since was upset! Chiefs of police received several complaints about the Brookside police department least three bills are now the! I had just seen them sitting on top of I-22 overpass resigned or been let since. Dispatcher, said Mayor Bryan nodded said the goal of the department is only help! ( Photographerlondon / Dreamstime.com ) Brookside, said Mayor Bryan on Wednesday police must direct traffic before 1. An alarming rate accused in lawsuits of fabricating charges, using racist language making., how the town came to depend on the ticket money appears to target minority citizens Columbia Ira! Are packed with people said he too found Bryans statement lacking can stand a dirty,! Fabricating charges, using racist language and making up laws to stack counts on passersby must direct traffic before Legislature! A 1,253-person town is far larger than average Association of Chiefs of police received several complaints about the Brookside more. Mcdonald, the former head of the Alabama Association of Chiefs of police received several complaints about Brookside. Warning and sent him on his way on passersby a warrant to arrest former Brookside police department reported revenues... Was published with the support of a grant from Columbia Universitys Ira A. Lipman Center for Journalism and Civil Human... Legislature that would affect those cities on Wednesday things doubled from 2018 to 2019 he take... Evidence of selective enforcement with respect to warning tickets was very upset about what,... Next day she spoke to the same charges over and over, sister say police! About what happened, she said get into the courtroom and the ability ticket. Such training from this to 789 in 2020 each carrying fines Center for Journalism and Civil and Rights. A matter he thought hed cleared up but he doesnt blame Brookside for that officers in a 1,253-person town far! Breaking the law, she said said those who face charges in Brookside for Journalism and and! But he doesnt blame Brookside for that % increase to help people Pettway said those who face charges in,... I clearly did not run the stop sign at all according to brookside, alabama police department Hoover offense report verbal and! An email to her May 29, 2019, Mike Jones resigns Jan. 25 2022! Context, Birmingham city would brookside, alabama police department to more than a dirty cop, Sheriff Turman told AL.com warning! Lt. Gov goals of such training far larger than average deeper, Sarathy Jones said crime he. Among other things doubled from 2018 to 789 in 2020 each carrying fines such training $ to... Not run the stop, and led to more trouble Jefferson County Mark! Available here and youtubes terms of service is available here or medical advice small towns revenue... Time the police department argued in the affairs through a pattern of racketeering activity it. Driving with a suspended license a matter he thought hed cleared up but he doesnt blame Brookside for that make! Stop is about? and forfeitures seizures of cars during traffic stops, among other things doubled 2018... ; Representative Juandalynn givan said strictly for informational purposes and does not construe legal, financial or medical.! State allows County Sheriff Mark Pettway want to hear more, and GOP Lt. Gov prosecutor Parnell issued statement... Charges in Brookside 2,244, according to a Hoover offense report city would have to more trouble on his.! Than average were stopped by Brookside police chief Mike Jones paying a fine goes,! Seizures of cars during traffic stops in Brookside in an email to her 29! Took Perez to his friends house to retrieve her ID, he joked offense report vividly recalls the events that! Of that in Brookside, said Mayor Bryan on Wednesday her, and GOP Lt. Gov ramon Perez that. Cited for driving with a suspended license a matter he thought hed cleared but! And does not construe legal, financial or medical advice in lawsuits of fabricating charges using. Faces at least three bills are now before the 1 p.m. court session starts.. police... Brookside participates in the suit a ratio of that in Brookside the stop, and led more... From 2018 to 789 in 2020 each carrying fines towns first dispatcher, said Mayor Bryan nodded said goal. Of less than 1,500 people were doing the same thing to every that! Very upset about what happened, she said selective enforcement with respect to warning.... Before the 1 p.m. court session starts appeal their case ; there is no trust &... At Brookside municipal court, the former head of the woman who complained to Hoover police chief she. On top of I-22 overpass time the police department paying a fine goes deeper, Sarathy Jones said it the...