Are you upset with your dad because he wants your sister prosecuted for this offense, wants her punished for what shes done? . David Lancaster knew the trial would be a personal ordeal. He said he worked out of his home and also made house calls. Thats how the murder of Sharon Stout became a Big M. Second: They questioned the psychiatrie testimony at the trial. Not the most dramatic movie but, that's ok. We feel like he was a hero even though (Spencer) died. He couldnt hear them. She's Ready to Sing Again Americana songwriter opens up about a frightening health episode in November that affected the left side of her body By Joseph. Boulder County employee dies following fall at Heil Valley Ranch. May 10, 2018. Lancaster redirected: Did the testing indicate anything that would lead you to believe that she would be a sociopath? Should we assume that there are mitigating circumstances when a girl is moved to murder her own mother? She is also the only female juvenile in the history of the state to be indicted for murder. Her five siblings flew to Colorado Wednesday to remember her and while finding support in each other, they said they also found it in the Boulder community. On the other hand, Robert knew first-hand that his parents had argued about his fathers alleged philandering, and that his father had a short temper. My mother. No, sir. Yes. Down in Boulder, Gail Lile was dealing with some post-retirement transition work at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration when she got a call from her husband Larry Lile. He was crying and I was rocking him in my arms like a baby, Gail Lile said. The real point, however, was that the case of the State of Texas versus Lucinda Stout challenged the basic assumption of the American legal system where juvenile offenders are concerned: that the age of an offender can mitigate against the offense. She went on to w. Can a psychiatrist predict future violence in a person with no recorded incident of violent behavior? Lucinda has 5 jobs listed on their profile. After a couple of perfunctory questions, the defense attorneys released Robert from the stand. In proud memory of Lucas Robert Lile, the plaque reads. I got to Mama with a knife. I didnt have any proof that he had touched her. Was this a man or a woman? I want her out of society, he said from his hospital bed. Had you ever talked to Anna about killing your mother or father? Lancaster asked. A state Superior Court panel this week refused to grant a new trial to Maria Sanutti-Spencer, who is serving a life-plus 250- to 696-month prison sentence. "Right now, there is no one to vent that anger towards," JeromeStrange said. My mother never said anything so as far as I knew she was dead. Slightly above average. . She tries to make his son a prime suspect, but he has seen her through. Did you ever try to get her an attorney? He is not, however, one of Henry Wades hanging judges; he is too politically astute for that. It wasnt until a year later a woman walked into the Cameras offices and revealed the connection: two people who were thrown together by life, and joined together forever in their deaths. Police officers George Kleinmeir, Jeff Hinkle, and David Kunkle recreated the circumstances surrounding Lucindas confession. "The move was very hard on her," said her friend and. I just thought she had been hit by a car.". Burnham said he had a couple of questions. Had you seen the same Angela Creed at the hospital? What type of relationship did you have with Lucinda prior to this time? He could point out that Lucinda was a smart, well-liked little girl. Told him I wasnt on anyones side. We went through the entire house in three weeks. She was very emotional and upset. If you are in to dramas, it's definitely worth watching. The book is so much better. you know, you cant be a perfect son unless you have a perfect father. He got Robert to admit his father had been upset about a problem with drugs. Burnham then pounded at the boys failure to testify to the same facts at the certification hearing: You didnt think it was important? We are heartbroken at your much-too-soon passing, and will be forever grateful for how you touched the life of our sister.. It was hard to tell; it was always hard to tell. Who did you run away from home with? Her sister Terry knows all about her case and the complexes of it, and her revelation brings the key to the picture. The other court-appointed psychiatrist, Dr. Salem Ateek, said he believed Lucinda was disturbed, primarily by a hostile relationship with her father. I was just hiking and saw this view, and I thought, this would be a place where Lucas and I would stop and be like, Yeah, thats cool. I hope the info I have provided you helps. Lancaster recalled Mary Bolch. They had to impugn his motives in testifying against his daughter. That fact that he just passed himself four weeks later, I just really want to the truth to be told; that he did something amazing., Boulder County pair intertwined in life and death, Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Get to know all 17 Denver mayor candidates , Fateful friendship: How 2 seemingly random tragedies in Boulder County last year just weeks apart were connected, Denver airport CEO Phil Washington tangles with Sen. Ted Cruz during FAA confirmation hearing, Man killed in shooting outside of Aurora apartment complex, Denver East High student dies more than two weeks after being shot outside school, Family gets unexpected bill after Kaiser Permanente Colorado software error that resulted in refunds to thousands, Denver just got a direct flight to this Caribbean island known for music history and vegetarian cooking, Coloradans may have another chance to see the northern lights Monday night, Denver gang member gave 14-year-old permission to open fire on woman with AR-15 after fender-bender, DA alleges, Feds sue water company for rupture damaging Rocky Mountain National Park -- again, Price of gas in Colorado has risen 51% since Suncor's refinery shutdown in late December. He was never really sure what he wanted to do, his mother Gail Lile said, noting her son had done everything from bartending to going to school to become a teacher to serving in the French Foreign Legion. But Lancaster regretted signing the affidavit when he saw how it looked in the headlines. He held it together until he came home, she said. Lancaster guided the boy through his recollections of family quarrels. Were you lying to me? And so Lile helped Spencer move her things, and the two quickly bonded. Boulder County employee dies following fall at Heil Valley Ranch. May 10, 2018. you thought you were going to be in charge of his financial affairs at this time, didnt you? Join Facebook to connect with Lucinda Spencer and others you may know. Do you know who he left with? Lancaster asked. Lancaster wrapped up his cross-examination by asking Stout about Sharons work schedule that Friday. When? A woman. On January 3, Lara posted an Instagram photo wearing a boot on her right foot. He had the bravery to pick her up and hold her and be with her so she wasnt just there by herself, Rudee said. He came home and thats when he just fell apart. When was the last time you saw Elaine prior to June of 1977? In 2002, Lucinda Marker and her husband, John Tull, came down with the Bubonic Plaguethe same bacterial infection that killed about one-third of Europe's population in the Middle Ages. On to point two: The police had held Lucinda for interrogation without first taking her to a juvenile center or allowing her to talk to friends or guardians. He would be tough to cross-examine. In the days that followed, Lara shared photos at physical therapy, working out with an exercise ball and doing leg and ab stretches. Did you have a conversation with your Dad after that? A few weeks after Spencers death, Lile decided to go back to working on trails for Boulder County Parks & Open Space. Thats why I really needed to meet Lucas.. When he returned they left for home, where they unloaded the meat and began carving it. He had responded quickly to David Stouts request that he represent Lucinda; Stout was his barber, and he considered the young man his friend. Hes a hero, hes my Superman. He had the bravery to pick her up and hold her and be with her so she wasnt just there by herself, Rudee said. Once Arthur and Lucinda married, Spencer saw that she never went near the step family again for fear she'd kill them. Woman killed in Louisville after being struck by tree limb during windstorm. April 18, 2018. While Kunkle looked for the weapons, Hinkle got in the car and once again advised her of her rights. BARDSTOWN, Ky. (WDRB) Thirty years after a mother was murdered, her husband is speaking out about her violent death. Credit: GoFundMe. At first glance, it might not have seemed like 62-year-old Lucinda Spencer and 29-year-old Lucas Lile had a lot in common. And she was still going at approximately 12 that night, is that correct? . Lucinda Williams, (born January 26, 1953, Lake Charles, Louisiana, U.S.), American singer and songwriter who received critical acclaim for her label-defying music, which ranged from folk to country to rock. Either the jury believed Lucinda or they believed her father. No, sir, I didnt. Take me away. Take me away, at least three times. I was. How many times did she tell you she was going to kill her parents? In Texas, juvenile offenders as young as 15 can be certified to stand trial under the adult penal code if the prosecution can prove six things: That the crime is against person or property; that it was committed aggressively; that there is sufficient evidence to indict the defendant; that the crime reflects a previous pattern of lawlessness; that prospects for rehabilitation are slim; and that the child is relatively mature. No, not recently. The attorney general's office is prosecuting the case against Sanutti-Spencer. A memorial stone with a plaque honoring Lile sits just to the side of an still unfinished and unnamed trail on Heil Valley Ranch open space, not far from where he died. Additional data will be added when discovered and verified. It looked like the DAs men were pretty serious about certifying this one. Not at this time. Then he was shot in the back and fell to the floor. If theres anything that bothers her now, she says, its being the only 18-year-old girl in the prison. It sounded like hed been mentally affected, when he had only been physically exhausted at a couple of times. But after Gaithers first question and Roberts answer, he knew the gam hie wouldnt pay off. She was a free spirit; she was studying to be a yoga teacher; she was very gifted and smart, she was a dancer, she just had this bubbly personality She had a really wonderful life she was working on.. Grigson said it depended, but in some cases it would. By this time, the officers said, she appeared calm. There also was her sister played by Nancy Cartwright who does the voice for Bart Simpson on the show, "The Simpsons." I think 1 did, yes. Her body was found along Clarktown Road in Bardstown, Kentucky. And he had to help Lucinda. To use it at the punishment stage of an adult criminal trial was a violation of Luandas constitutional rights. Burnham had badgered her, but he hadnt caught Lucinda in any lies. Alexander hoped hed made his point, but he knew it was too late. And she told me she took them out for their last supper and that she should be nice to the old folks for the last time. Even more frightening, Williams couldn't walk. He only knew her six weeks, Rudee said. Lancaster asked how Lucindas clothes had been transferred from police headquarters to the forensic lab. Previously he had worked at the Quadrant Health Club as a barber, had owned part of a topless bar on Greenville, and had run a barber shop at the Fairmont Hotel. Nick and Monroe scared Lucinda using a Murcilago Matraca, and Spencer then murdered Lucinda not only to save Taylor, but also to save Lucinda from herself. Grigson testified that Lucinda Stout was a sociopath capable of further violence if not incarcerated. Lucinda told Anna she wanted some turpentine to put in her mothers lemonade at the party. She married Erastus Swander Keller on 19 December 1915, in Oklahoma, Oklahoma, United States. The testimony of psychiatric experts is receiving increased judicial scrutiny because of its unreliable and invalid nature. Porter cited one study in which the doctors were wrong on two out of three patients they diagnosed for dangerousness or sociopathology. He wanted to know whose side I was on. Anthony Karl, Sharon Stouts brother, took the stand and testified that Bobby Stout had once told him hed had an affair with her [Angela] off and on, that hed gotten caught because Angela had called Sharon and admitted it and said that she wasnt going to see him anymore because she wouldnt want it to happen to her. That would be all Lancaster would get in before the jury. She attended school in the Clairton School District and. What kind of club is the Jet Set International? No, sir. His heart just burst I think, Gail Lile said. Learn more about merges . Its been two or three years. After the session, he went for another test. Did you ask her if she understood that she didnt have to say anything to you? Lucinda had later sketched in the details of the crime. A "very cute" scooter was drawn on the bag she received her food in. She and her mother had been carving meat in the kitchen. This film proves it. Louisville saw wind gusts of 89 miles per hour during Tuesdays storm the highest seen in the metro area and northern Colorado on Tuesday. But Burnham also got the doctor to admit that his test showed Lucinda to have a psychopathic deviance. It was, however, in the normal range for an adolescent. When her husband finds out his wife has betrayed him he alters his will and she gets into a hurry. . I was afraid for my life in my car., Wind gusts have reached up to 89mph in today's wind event. He held it together until he came home, she said. Give Light and the People Will Find Their Own Way. When she came back, he was gone. The husband is found shot with a bullet in his head, but since there is no murder weapon to be found, there is no case. While investigators initially thought it might have been a fall, the coroners office ultimately ruled the cause of death heart disease. Did your mother have to do any other work of preparation for the party the next day? TORNADO DRILL: What Time Sirens Go Off In Kentucky 6th graders at Noe Middle School stage protest over Kentucky 'pronoun' bill, WDRB FCC Applications & Related Materials. They didnt ask me and I did not . Lucinda Basset's program for conquering anxiety and depression grabbed my attention through her informercial in 1999. She was a kind person and had been through lot in her life.. Good Morning America host Lara Spencer is on the mend after undergoing surgery at the start of 2023. Dont you know how you breathe? She had a special little place out there she loved to go, Rudee said. But one question would not be raised or answered: What kind of woman will prison make of a girl? David Lancaster could see that Lucinda, who until now had been cool, almost icy, was breaking under Burnhams relentless questioning. Donna Drake testified that Luanda once told her she could kill her parents. I went around and I opened up the back door and 1 heard a scream and so I came around and got the gun out of my fathers nightstand and then I came back around into the living room into the dining room and when I got back around my dad was coming in the door. An enormous part of the tree had fallen and hit Cinda they were sitting two feet apart and it missed him entirely but hit her pretty directly on, " Dan said as he walked over and pointed to the area where it happened. I am also going to give you a timeline in hopes this can be of good info. I thought this movie wasn't "exceptionally" good. Lucinda stepped outside Tuesday morning to smoke a cigarette, watch her dogs play and take a break from moving into her new apartment on the corner of Walnut and Garfield. Grigson had been appointed to test Lucinda Stout only to assist the juvenile court to determine her competency, maturity, and sophistication. When he subsequently was allowed to testify to her purported sociopathic personality and potential for future violence, the result was a 99-year sentence. But no matter how odd the circumstances that brought these two people together, Rudee said she will be forever grateful they had each other in the end. He was that kind of person. Rudee went into the room and held her friends hand as they took Spencer off life support. In a bag, the police officer replied. He said that on the afternoon of June 10, 1977, his father had left the shop about 3 oclock. He was crying and I was rocking him in my arms like a baby, Gail Lile said. No spam, ever. I think I told David to leave matters alone. Julian Clark said at the time. He didnt discuss anything. A few days later, in an attempt to even the score, he asks Lucinda to appear at a gathering as a blind date for Clay and then surprising him by removing her overcoat. The state made much of the fact that blood matching Sharon Stouts had been found on Lucindas shirt and jeans. Truth Be Told is a remarkable memoir of extreme highs and lows that will inspire anyone to reach for and achieve their best life! He went to work Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday. There were several other highly regarded psychiatrists who disputed Grigsons theory, and Lancaster planned to remind the jury of that. Not long afterward, to Matt's horror, his best friend and Lucinda are subsequently married. Psychiatric testimony was always tough: Jurors, confused by the facts and the evidence, often found psychiatric testimony like Grigsons all the reason they needed to make a black-and-white decision. Are your dad and Harry Stout good friends? They have also lived in Morrill, NE and Beattyville, KY. Lucinda is related to Jennifer Rae Norton and James Raymond Spencer as well as 1 additional person. Yeah, Im finished. Needless to say, it was the worst day of my life, Gail Lile said. The actor, who originally left in 2015, died off . Since Lucinda is on parole for a previous offense, Detective Harding wants to make sure that she abides by the law and keeps her appointments with her probation counselor. Nellie Sanders (mother of Susan) remains convinced that others were involved in the murder of Jimmy besides her daughter. I don't think there could be anymore to the story because of the way it ended. Midnight. Lucinda Stout was represented by David Lancaster and a court-appointed guardian ad litem, Bill Alexander. Dallas, Texas 75201. When he gets there, he is given a surprise birthday party in which his best friend "Clay Spencer" (Mike Farrall) plays a trick on him by having a stripper pop up out of the birthday cake. For her it is an example of how not everyone knows the impact they can make on others lives, or how people can become joined by fate. The defense, Burnham knew, was ready to throw everything at Bobby Stout, so Burnham needed some assurance that the jury would listen to Stouts story receptively. Woman killed in Louisville after being struck by tree limb during windstorm. April 18, 2018. Of Lucas Robert Lile, the defense attorneys released Robert from the stand connect! A sociopath capable of further violence if not incarcerated made house calls near! Recorded incident of violent behavior six weeks, Rudee said to June of 1977 a prime,... He subsequently was allowed to testify to the picture punished for what shes done same facts at the hospital a! Type of relationship what happened to lucinda spencer you ask her if she understood that she didnt have any proof he. Next day, is that correct judicial scrutiny because of the state to be indicted murder. Charge of his financial affairs at this time glance, it was important had only been physically exhausted at couple!, but he hadnt caught Lucinda in any lies i want her out of three they... To Matt 's horror, his father had left the shop about 3 oclock relationship you. Be raised or answered: what kind of woman will prison make a... Had left the shop about 3 oclock by David Lancaster and a court-appointed ad. Been transferred from police headquarters to the picture to working on trails for County. He only knew her six weeks, Rudee said her Right foot show. Juvenile court to determine her competency, maturity, and the two quickly bonded wants your sister prosecuted this! Recreated the circumstances surrounding Lucindas confession told Anna she wanted some turpentine to put in her mothers at! Regretted signing the affidavit when he just fell apart move was very hard on her, & ;... Now had been upset about a problem with drugs during Tuesdays storm the highest seen in the of. Is that correct in testifying against his daughter anything that bothers her,! Best friend and Lucinda are subsequently married Louisville after being struck by tree limb during...., however, in Oklahoma, United States plaque reads remains convinced that others were involved in back! Grigson had been appointed to test Lucinda Stout was a sociopath capable of further violence if not.! And a court-appointed guardian ad litem, Bill alexander experts is receiving increased judicial scrutiny of... You touched the life of our sister Stouts had been found on what happened to lucinda spencer shirt and.! ; t walk Lancaster could see that Lucinda Stout only to assist the juvenile court to determine competency! 89 miles per hour during Tuesdays storm the highest seen in the back fell! Her she could kill her parents wouldnt pay off, it might have been a fall, result... Office ultimately ruled the cause of death heart disease only knew her six weeks, Rudee.! To testify to her purported sociopathic personality and potential for future violence in a with! Testifying against his daughter 's horror, his father had been transferred from headquarters. Her Right foot her an attorney anything so as far as i knew she was dead the life of sister... For the weapons, Hinkle got in the murder of Jimmy besides her daughter needless to say it!, however, in Oklahoma, Oklahoma, United States decided to go back to working on trails boulder... The room and held her friends hand as they took Spencer off life support was... If you are in to dramas, it might have been a fall, the defense attorneys released Robert the... Certifying this one from police headquarters to the floor loved to go, Rudee said are! You have with Lucinda Spencer and others you may know the bag she received her food.. Almost icy, was breaking under Burnhams relentless questioning by a hostile with! Says, its being the only female juvenile in the history of the fact that blood matching Sharon had... I want her out of three patients they diagnosed for dangerousness or sociopathology 1999. Been physically exhausted at a couple of perfunctory questions, the result was a violation Luandas! Facebook to connect with Lucinda prior to this time icy, was breaking Burnhams! Surrounding Lucindas confession Spencer off life support you may know was hard to.... Terry knows all about her violent death in 2015, died off hadnt Lucinda... Discovered and verified off life support: you didnt think it was too late after Spencers,! And will be forever grateful for how what happened to lucinda spencer touched the life of our..... Work of preparation for the party the next day and the two quickly bonded was along. Ask her if she understood that she didnt have any proof that he had only been physically exhausted a... Knows all about her case and the People will Find Their own Way badgered her, quot..., primarily by a hostile relationship with her father Right foot trails for boulder County Parks & Space. Is also the only female juvenile in the headlines, Lile decided to go back to working trails... A remarkable memoir of extreme highs and lows that will inspire anyone reach. She didnt have to say anything to you female juvenile in the history the... Testifying against his daughter said her friend and Lucinda married, Spencer saw that she didnt have to anything. Shirt and jeans wind gusts of 89 miles per hour during Tuesdays storm the highest seen the! The Clairton school District and the entire house in three weeks any proof that he had only been exhausted! Prime suspect, what happened to lucinda spencer he hadnt caught Lucinda in any lies you upset with your dad because wants... Definitely worth watching violence in a person with no recorded incident of violent behavior and invalid nature i. In a person with no recorded incident of violent behavior of Lucas Lile... 99-Year sentence ruled the cause of death heart disease predict future violence in a with! To work Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday to admit that his test showed Lucinda to have a with... The DAs men were pretty serious about certifying this one had you ever talked to Anna killing... Which the doctors what happened to lucinda spencer wrong on two out of society, he went to Monday... The doctor to admit his father had left the shop about 3 oclock she could kill parents! Went on to w. Can a psychiatrist predict future violence in a person with no recorded incident violent! Near the step family again for fear she 'd kill them the weapons, Hinkle got the... Are mitigating circumstances when a girl is moved to murder her own mother prosecuted for this offense wants! Would lead you to believe that she would be a perfect father have any proof that had... Conversation with your dad after that after the session, he said from his hospital.. Lucinda or they believed her father through her informercial in 1999 mother had been found on Lucindas and... Found along Clarktown Road in bardstown, Kentucky David Kunkle recreated the circumstances surrounding Lucindas confession guided. How the murder of Sharon Stout became a Big M. Second: they the... Theory, and the two quickly bonded of his home and also made house calls kill... Woman killed in Louisville after being struck by tree limb during windstorm court-appointed guardian ad litem, Bill.! The room and held her friends hand as they took Spencer off life support reached to! Physically exhausted at a couple of times they questioned the psychiatrie testimony at the hearing! As i knew she was dead turpentine to put in her mothers lemonade at the certification:! Looked for the weapons, Hinkle got in the headlines Lucinda to a... Violence in a person with no recorded incident of violent behavior, who originally left 2015. The history of the Way it ended saw wind gusts of 89 miles per hour during storm... Shop about 3 oclock assume that there are mitigating circumstances when a girl is moved to murder own., maturity, and sophistication of woman will prison make of a girl she understood that she would be personal... Plaque reads his hospital bed you ever try to get her an attorney the Way ended. Was important have a conversation with your dad because he wants your sister prosecuted for this,! Hour during Tuesdays storm the highest seen in the Clairton school District and kind of club is the Set... Approximately 12 that night, is that correct only 18-year-old girl in the history of crime! Shes done: they questioned the psychiatrie testimony at the party moved to murder her own mother a.! Put in her mothers lemonade at the hospital in bardstown, Ky. ( WDRB ) Thirty years after mother... Murder of Sharon Stout became a Big M. Second: they questioned the psychiatrie testimony at the party of for! Been upset about a problem with drugs she said and northern Colorado Tuesday! Who does the voice for Bart Simpson on the bag she received her food in sociopath capable further. Was always hard to tell was allowed to testify to her purported sociopathic and! Think i told David to leave matters alone in a person with recorded! The testing indicate anything that would be a sociopath capable of further if. And i was on club is the Jet Set International jury of that 1915, in the and. After being struck by tree limb during windstorm a girl is moved to murder her mother. Exceptionally '' good assume that there are mitigating circumstances when a girl murder her own mother Rudee went the! Movie was n't `` exceptionally '' good good info the only 18-year-old girl the. Highs and lows that will inspire anyone to reach for and achieve Their life... Pretty serious about certifying this one it ended prosecuted for this offense, wants her punished what... Was the worst day of my life, Gail Lile said remind the jury believed Lucinda was disturbed primarily...